[RCC]: Pelican Nebula

3 replies364 views
Jure Menart avatar
Hi all,

I'd like to ask for some feedback on my Pelican Nebula: https://www.astrobin.com/sbf9nw/C/

I had quite a lot of problems with this data (it was very humid) so I am happy to at least get something out. I also like the framing, which was one of first projects for me that I intentionally frame over multiple nights.

I think, I had some problems with flat calibration which usually works for me flawlessly. Blue channel (Oiii) was all around the place so it make the background extraction really hard, so I did it manually with color masks (based on combined Ha + Sii). So I know it's not perfect, but at the end I was quite happy with that. I also had huge issues to get some usable stars (I know the Cyg 56 has a lot of strange patterns, I could maybe clean it up a little bit better).

I used 'my standard' PixInsight flow (roughly):
- Background extraction - Usually I'd do it ASAP, but I actually couldn't do it with DBE/ABE so I 'equalize' it later in the processing, I even tried it with Graxpert without luck
- Combine SHO  & RGB channels
- StarXTerminator (throw away SHO stars & RGB starless)

SHO starless:
- BlurXTerminator
- Stretch to linear - with STF + histogram transformation, I intentionally didn't stretch a lot, I prefer to do it later with Curves
- ColorMask with original (starless) Ha+Sii (I use PixelMath to create mask) - lowering the background, trying to keep the lighter parts unchanges as much as possible
- ColorMask with Magenta, Green & Cyan (to remove magenta color, do the blue-orange)
- ColorMask green - to remove very green trend towards the left side (should usually be removed with background extraction)
- Final curves (on full image and with color masks)

RGB stars:
- BlurXterminator (very easy processing but with 'correct first' option)
- SPCC
- Stretch to linear - manually with histogram transformation

Combine SHO starless + RGB stars
- light NoiseXTerminator for finalization

Hopefully I didn't forget anything.
Helpful
Michael W. Dean avatar
This is better than most requests for criticism here.
Well Written
jewzaam avatar
I love the orientation and scale.  For my taste, it has a muted / hazy feel.  I'd probably create a L mask and use it inverted with histogram transformation and neutralize some of the background.  Probably is the green/blue in the dark areas throwing me a bit.
Jure Menart avatar
Michael W. Dean:
This is better than most requests for criticism here.

Thanks Michael, for your kind words! I wouldn't fully agree - there are really great images in RCC section I am fairly happy with my Pelican Nebula but something I think is missing... and it was though data IMHO to work with but thanks again!
I love the orientation and scale.  For my taste, it has a muted / hazy feel.  I'd probably create a L mask and use it inverted with histogram transformation and neutralize some of the background.  Probably is the green/blue in the dark areas throwing me a bit.

Hi jewzaam, I agree - this was the biggest struggle I had with this data. I will probably on one occasion use your advice and try to neutralize background even further (you should have seen it originally, how horrible it was ). I used Ha+Sii as a mask for BG neutralization but probably if I extract L on final image and just try to suppres BG a little bit more, it could give great result!

Thanks for good suggestion!
Related discussions
[RCC] Bubble Nebula (NGC 7635)
Hello all, Soliciting feedback on my image here… https://www.astrobin.com/g4jty8/ I used Pixinsight to create the masters and processed RGB stars separately, used Photoshop to get the nebulosity and used extracted Lum for details on the nebula ...
Similar nebula processing critique request with detailed workflow description.
Feb 6, 2022
Starless images, do you think they're OK?
A short prologue, I've recently started to separate the stars and DSO when I'm processing my images. I've found it a powerful technique for getting more detail out of the nebula without distorting or blowing out the stars. It's worth ...
Author processes nebula images; similar techniques and challenges to author's work.
May 14, 2022
Attacking weird background noise
Hello everyone, Since galaxy season is on, i started imaging M81/82 with my ASI533MC camera. After integrating my frames(PI or DSS),a weird red noise have been swamping my background and even though I tried everything (multiple DBEs/SCNR/RangeSelecti...
Red noise in broadband imaging; similar post-processing challenges with nebulae.
Mar 27, 2022
Lum+SHO Rosette Nebula Comments an Critiques
Okay, maybe I am just a glutton for punishment, but I would love to get feedback on this image. I really apperciated the feed back on my Heart and Soul SHO 135 mm project. This image is with my RASA8 using SHO data from 1 nigh in 2020 with my ASI 160...
Author requests image feedback; this post also seeks community critique.
Jan 8, 2022