Dominic avatar
Good evening.

The past few nights I've been trying to image M13. However, I've noticed I'm getting a fairly uniform elongation on the stars. I think it's roughly aligned with the RA axis.

This is the first time I've noticed the issue and I'm wondering if anyone has any idea what could be happening?

Any advice folks have would be great.
Well written Engaging
Uri Abraham avatar
Hi,

I can see in your latest image the elongated stars in one axis. There could be several reasons as you mentioned.
Do you see this in every frame or only in some ? If in some then reason could be wind gusts or seeing deviations during the session(s)  or intermittent guiding errors

Uri
Dominic avatar
Hi Uri,

It's in every frame unfortunately. I'm planning on doing some unguided exposures to see if the issue is the guiding.

Thanks
Douwe79 avatar
Hi Dominic,

Your image has the same north-south elongation as some of my (posted and unpostefd) images have and I am also trying to figure out what the cause is.
This week I also shot M13 with elongated stars. So for a second I thought the stars of M13 just changed their shape :-).

Was your guiding worse that night then normally? Even if I have decent guiding (0.6 - 0.7 total RMS) i have elongation, albeit that my stars look more like eggs.

If your image suffers from flexure, using an OAG can be the solution. I am now corresponding with other Astrobin member, he says you can check if its flexure by using PixelMath process in Pixinsight (dont know if you use that program). Haven't tried it yet.

Shooting very short exposure (max 5 sec) can tell if there is a problem with the optics. You can also do this guided. If the stars are not round, there can be an optical problem (both in telescope or in camera). If you have 2 telescopes and/or 2 camera's you can rule this out (or confirm of course).

Since I'm having this problem too, please update me on your findings.

CS,
Douwe
Helpful Engaging Supportive
Dominic avatar
Hi Douwe,

Thanks for the info. I'll definitely post my findings once I've had a chance to experiment a little.
Well written Respectful
Michel Makhlouta avatar
Hi Dominic,
I've been going through a similar problem which turned out to be vibrations from the camera's fan. Try taking 1 second exposures and see if the problem is there, and try with/without the 12V connected to the ASI.

I hope you get to the bottom of this soon, good luck!
Well written Concise Supportive
Rich Sky avatar
Could be your filter causing abberation
Related discussions
Weird Guiding Issue with OAG/Asiair Plus
I am quite new to the whole astrophotography thing, and have put together a fairly sophisticated system that I am perhaps a little under-skilled to use properly. It's been a few months since I had a chance to use my gear, since our Southern Hemis...
Star elongation may relate to guiding issues mentioned in OAG/Asiair post.
Apr 12, 2022
ASIAIR Pro RA Guiding Issues
Hi, Please see attached guide screen off the asiair pro app. I'm running an EQ6R-pro mount and an OAG with an asi290mm mini. Once the asiair starts to guide, RA nearly instantaneously rockets off, always to the positive side. I'm decently con...
RA axis elongation directly matches ASIAIR Pro RA guiding problems.
Sep 6, 2021
Can a clip filter distort images ?
I am using an astronomik MaxFR Ha 12nm clip filter in a canon Ra . I have noticed that the stars often do not align perfectly with unfiltered images, on the same camera and lens, in the corners and edges - maybe out by a couple of star widths. It’s f...
Filter distortion could cause star alignment and elongation issues.
Apr 1, 2022
Autoguiding with Planets
Good morning, In order to improve the quality of my planetary shots, I was going to try autoguiding with PHD. Has anyone tried this with planetary shots? Does it even work? I was concerned because my planetary scope has a fairly large focal length (1...
Star elongation issues may relate to guiding problems at high magnification.
Jan 8, 2019