RGB subs: very short for stars plus longer for nebula?

1 reply280 views
Frank Alvaro avatar
After about 18 months of using a OSC camera, I've just ventured into mono imaging.  I've seen that many people use brief subs to record RGB colour and longer and more numerous luminance subs for details.  I've done this for my first two LRGB images, using 30 second subs for R, G and B and 300 second subs for luminance, and they seemed to work out OK (see below). But I see that the stars still seem to have white, blown out cores, so I thought I should decrease the time for the RGB subs to something like 10 seconds...but then I wondered if this will be enough to capture colours in nebulosity. 

So my question is: would it make sense to take 10 second RGB subs just for star colours (not sure of the total duration - maybe 10 minutes each?)  and then longer and more RGB subs to get more nebula colour? The plan would be to extract the stars from the briefest processed RGB image, extract a starless image from the longer RGB image and process that, then combine those with the luminance. Would this necessarily make a better image, or would just using a large number of very short subs give me good star colour and sufficient nebulosity colour?

Frank



Corona Australis Nebula, NGC 6729




Eta Carina Nebula, NGC 3372
Helpful Engaging
andrea tasselli avatar
Your problem is more with the luminace data rather than with the RGB data. I'd suggest you process the RGB image properly (i.e., in line with the luminance one), extract the stars, create the LRGB , remove the stars and put the RGB star back into the LRGB image. BTW, you white point seems a triffle too low to me, if you want to show colors in the highlights.
Helpful Concise
Related discussions
What Could Be Causing This Random Noise All Of A Sudden?
Recently when processing data on several deep sky targets I've been imaging within the course of the last month, I've encountered seemingly unexplainable phenomenon with the stacked data, I am noticing very high levels of noise AFTER stretchi...
Nov 29, 2022
Both posts discuss technical challenges and experiences with luminance data in deep sky astrophotography processing.
Issue with flat frames
Hello everyone, I need some advice about flats. A few months ago, I switched to a monochrome camera with an IMX571 sensor (ToupTek ATR2600M), paired with a ToupTek filter wheel and Antlia LRGB filters. As my main telescope, I use an Askar 103 APO. I ...
May 6, 2025
Both posts discuss astrophotographers transitioning to monochrome cameras and working with LRGB (luminance, red, green, blue) filter imaging techniques.
Looking for Camera and Filter Wheel Recommendations
The biggest problems I have running NINA at home or at a remote observatory is 1) camera connectivity to NINA, and 2) the filter wheel getting stuck on one filter. When running at the remote site, I always have to make sure that the camera cools and ...
25 days ago
Both posts discuss technical aspects of astrophotography equipment and imaging techniques.
Mysterious star trailing solved: a cautionary tale of fan vibration with a fan cooled (especially ZWO) camera.
Suddenly after no problems with star shapes, the next night out they were just terrible! Below I show a gif comparing two 2 hr stacks, one with the good stars, and the next with elongated stars. In this example the distortion was vertical. But later ...
7 days ago
Both posts discuss technical challenges and experiences with astrophotography imaging techniques and equipment performance.
New to or Considering Astrophotography/astronomy?
I had posted this with a new image I’d uploaded as a change from the “typical” review of my processing steps/acquisition. A friend/commentor suggested I post in a forum, so this is the result. This is VERY subjective and based entirely on my experien...
Jul 31, 2025
Both posts discuss personal experiences and learning processes in astrophotography, with one sharing techniques for mono imaging and LRGB processing while the other offers subjective advice for newcomers to the hobby.