Software: Deep Sky Stacker or Photoshop?

6 replies176 views
schmaks avatar
Hi,

Is everyone using something like Deep Sky Stacker to stack or is anyone doing everything within Photoshop?

Curious about the process and results from each.

Thanks!
Well Written Engaging
Wouter D'hoye avatar
Hi,

Deep sky stacker is only good for deep sky imaging. For solar system imaging Autostakkert is much better and me program of choice. Note however that autostakkert does just that, stack the images from an AVI or SER file. Further processing is done in different software. I use lynkeos (MAC) for deconvolution sharpening, and afterwards Adobe Phootooshop for final image frocessing.

Clear skies,

Wouter
Helpful Concise
Kevin Morefield avatar
Hi,Is everyone using something like Deep Sky Stacker to stack or is anyone doing everything within Photoshop?

Curious about the process and results from each.

Thanks!


Photoshop picks up pretty much where DeepSkyStacker stops. So I don’t think it’s an either/or with those two.

It’s very common here for someone to use Pixinsight, CCDStack, or one of a few other astrophoto specific programs to do the stacking and produce a TIFF and then many will migrate to Photoshop for the finishing touches.

That, of course, is for traditions deep-sky images.  Planetary, lucky imaging and EAA often follow different software paths using Autostakkart or Sharpcap as an example.
Well Written Helpful
Rich Sky avatar
DSS is for stacking, photoshop I don't think will do that. If you have a colour ccd or camera, DSS will debayer the image and again, not sure if photoshop will debayer the image.
Photoshop is not needed for AP, unless you wish to ambelish your images, which I never do.
and StarTools for Mac but you already know that. Beyond ST, pixinsight and other software.

For planets, yes, autostakker (video stacking) and StarTools.
Clear skies smile
schmaks avatar
Rich Sky:
DSS is for stacking, photoshop I don't think will do that. If you have a colour ccd or camera, DSS will debayer the image and again, not sure if photoshop will debayer the image.Photoshop is not needed for AP, unless you wish to ambelish your images, which I never do.
and StarTools for Mac but you already know that. Beyond ST, pixinsight and other software.

For planets, yes, autostakker (video stacking) and StarTools.
Clear skies


Thanks, Rich!

I’ve seem some people using photoshop for everything with impressive results using the stitch batch process to stack, etc.

That said, it doesn’t appear many on here are doing that so I’m guessing there is a reason for that.
Rich Sky avatar
Regim is another one by Andreas Roerig. Works well.

https://www.andreasroerig.de/regim/regim.xhtml
Min Xie avatar
Another great option is the Astro Pixel Processor.
Well Written
Related discussions
APP vs DSS vs Pixinsight
As a noob in this field, I am learning about a number of pieces of software to stack and process images. So far, my early efforts have used Deep Sky Stacker and Photoshop, but I wonder whether I should move to something like Pixinsight or Astropixel ...
Compares DSS with other stacking software options like APP and Pixinsight.
Jun 11, 2021
Need help with SHO processing software. GIMP, APP, PI or other?
I'm fairly new to AP and have been using GIMP to process all of my current astro images. I use DSS to stack. I just recently switched to a mono camera (asi294mm Pro) and collected my first set of SHO subs but having a difficult time processing th...
Discusses DSS stacking and alternative processing software choices.
Aug 14, 2021
Bizarre Stacking Artifacts In DSS
Hello all, I am processing some data I collected on the Tadpole Nebula in Deep Sky Stacker, and got a surprising–and distressing result! The entire image is suffused with a blocky quilt pattern. (See attachment, which is slightly stretched but ...
Addresses specific issues encountered while stacking in Deep Sky Stacker.
Dec 31, 2021
Pixinsight v photoshop
It’s probably been asked thousands of times but I’m asking for peoples thoughts. I currently use notes to work with photoshop, and have a nightmare remembering how to navigate through it. This is usually not like me because I’m from a technical backg...
Directly compares Pixinsight and Photoshop for astrophotography processing.
Oct 6, 2021