Matching a Telescope to a camera - Image Scale/Sampling (side by side tests)

5 replies233 views
Rouz Astro avatar
I have been testing image scale and focal length variations for some time now and complied some interesting results.

 With the long focal length CDK14, I noticed images at native are a bit soft.Finally around to a side by side test.

Picked a target and imaged 2 hours at the native 2565mm and then 2 hours at a shorter focal length of 1700mm - keeping other factors constant.

Yes, the image at the reduced focal length was smaller - but it was up sampled to 150% to match the native one. 

Here you could say its not "real" information and its the software interpolating the data - that is true.However, with an excessively oversampled image, its the same case - at my native 7x sampling rate, there is no "real" data there either.

That's also just blowing up the image scale for the sake of making it larger without any real data. Perhaps other can chime in, but I don't notice any real resolution gain past 4x the seeing.

There are some here that feel 7x is possible, my hats off to them! The disadvantages are obvious - far dimmer image and much lower SNR, much smaller FOV.   

Yes you can bin, but it would be nice to have a 62Mpixel image with a much larger FOV. 

Wrote an article on the topic as well -  
https://rouzastro.com/guides/
Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging
Rouz Astro avatar
Here is the difference in ADUs

Rouz Astro avatar
FOV gain

Rouz Astro avatar
Long focal length vs shorter+resample This was on the same night - so back to back. The target had moved to a lower altitude:

Rouz Astro avatar
I found it interesting that that there was no loss in resolution at all. It was clear the next night so I imaged the same target exactly the same and this time with reduced focal length at the same altitude as the previous night with the longer focal length. Here everything is the same including the altitude.

Rouz Astro avatar
With the increased brightness, I then compared the results with integration time: f/7.2 with 10 x 600sf/4.7 with 6 x 600s Both had similar SNR (pixinsgiht) and looked similar visually. Note we are using about half the time at f/4.7

Related discussions
How bad is over-sampling?
Matching pixel-size to focal length sounds great, but in reality most modern CMOS cameras have pixels of 3.8 micron (few exceptions). So most of us with a long focal-length of around 2m and more (SCT's, RC's, CDK's etc.) will have highly ...
Discusses pixel-size matching and oversampling issues relevant to your focal length tests.
Sep 19, 2024
Drizzle/Binning/Resampling
Fellow Astrophotographers, i am having a day off and thanks to the bad weather no new data to process, so I decided to make a comparison of (the same) differently sampled luminance data of my latest project. what do we look at? https://www.astrobin.c...
Directly compares drizzle, binning, and resampling techniques you used in your upsampling test.
Dec 22, 2024
Fast Scope vs Large Aperture
I tried to get some feedback on another forum but it was crickets so I am going to try here where there is good conversation. So I have literally spent hours reading about this the last few days. I am not nearly as smart as many of the people in this...
Explores focal length and aperture trade-offs similar to your native vs. reduced focal length comparison.
Feb 20, 2025
CMOS (Software) Binning, When and How?
Hi, I'm still searching for a good solution for my workflow. With my 8" SCT (reduced to f/7) and my CMOS, I would end up with approximately 0.35"p.pxl. I've integrated the unbinned data and worked with different integer downsampling...
Compares image scale and sampling matching between telescopes and cameras systematically.
Jun 20, 2021
Processing Pleiades , newbie here!
Hello everyone, This is my first post here, I am very new to this hobby and recently I bought a SW star adventurer 2i pro pack and combined with a nikon D5300 dslr and 200mm f3.5 lens (L-Bracket with counterweight) , I took a shot at M45 from my bort...
Author uses 200mm lens with DSLR; image scale and focal length matching applicable.
Nov 13, 2021