What makes a good astrophotograph?

1 reply156 views
IrishAstro4484 avatar
Might sound like a strange/obvious question but I'd be interested to hear what people think are the key attributes of a high quality astrophotograph. 

Off the top of my head I would say such a photograph should have several of the following attributes;

1. In focus round and symmetric star profiles.

2. High resolution/contrast to detect subtle details in the target and surrounding areas…. 

3. Minimal noise (through appropriate use of stacking and noise reduction techniques).

4. Minimal or no artefacts (light gradients, dirt/dust motes, amp glow…. Etc). 

5. Sensible colour profile ( probably a discussion in its own right). 

6. Minimal or no saturation in the target itself or surrounding stars/areas. 

I'm aware quite a number of factors influence this including equipment & software used/acquisition techniques & processing/environmental conditions and skills levels/goals of the astrophotographer. 

I don't think there is necessarily a right or wrong answer but I'd be interested to know if there are features of an astrophotograph that most people can agree should be present to some extent for it to be considered a high quality astrophotograph.


Any thoughts?
Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging
Emmanuel Valin avatar
Hi Robert,

I asked myself the same a while ago.

Here is a summary of the answers I found:
https://www.astrobin.com/irhgt3/

CS,

Emmanuel
Related discussions
[RCC] Cave Nebula (Sh2-155) from last summer
I thought the following image was possibly my best from 2020, but after several months, it has not received as many "likes" from my followers as a few others from the same time period. Cave nebula (Sh2-155) I have the following specific que...
Directly addresses what makes astrophotography high quality; author seeking feedback.
Jan 18, 2021
[RCC] Beginner Orion Nebula Feedback
To preface: This is the first 'completed' image that I have gone through the entire process with calibration frames and processing. Just starting this hobby as of December 2020, I have done some minor experiments before with stacking 2 images...
Discusses key attributes of high quality astrophotographs; directly relevant to seeking constructive criticism.
Mar 25, 2021
FSQ85 in 2024 or ???
Hi everyone, I'm currently considering purchasing a new optic for astrophotography. At the moment, I have a Redcat 91 here, but unfortunately, it has a noticeable defect and will be returned to the dealer. Before this, I had an FRA300, but it sho...
Discusses specific telescope equipment choices relevant to astrophotography quality and performance.
Dec 28, 2024