Jerry Gerber:
Hello!
The Esprit 100 ED manual says that the backfocus, when using the field flattener that comes with the telescope and the ZWO ASI2600MC, should be 63mm.
A tech person at Sky Watcher says the backfocus with same setup should be 55mm.
The field flattener comes with an 8mm spacer/adapter but if I remove it from the image train none of the ZWO extenders will screw into the flattener itself, there's a thread-size mismatch.
Is the backfocus 63mm or 55? If anyone has solved this, please share this with me!
Thanks,
Jerry
Jerry,
It is both!
Yes, I know confusing. I have an Esprit 100ED and the information is in the owners guide although it could be stated more clearly. The "true" back focus from the front face of the field flattener is 63mm. BUT...
If you look closely at the FF as packaged (and this is indicated in the users guide), there is an adapter on it for mating up the normal threads/attachments for whatever components you will install. That adapter takes up 8mm of backspace, which leaves... 55mm! The confusion is because Skywatcher has the 8mm thick adapter already installed on the field flattener and it looks like it is a part of the FF as a result
You can replace that adapter. In fact you will need for to some configurations.
For instance, in my setup with an OAG-L on the front end, EFW 2"x7, and ASG Photon Cage + 2600mm, I needed to adapt directly to the face of the OAG-L to stay within the required back focus and still provide a bit of play for adjusting out tilt/fine tuning the back focus with the ASG Photon Cage (which consumes 3mm of BF).
One thing you need to understand is that the Esprit 100ED is a mass produced telescope (or what passes for mass production from China) so there are tolerances in the stated specs. Once you start imaging and if you use apps that determine the actual pixel resolution of your rig based on image analysis, you shouldn't be surprised if they report a very slightly different focal length that the stated spec. Modern tilt/bf focus analysis tools like those in the HocusFocus plug-in for the N.I.N.A. sequence manager may show that your "real" back focus is different than the stated spec as well.
In my case, SkyX, and the analysis tools in PixInsight have demonstrated that my "real" focal length is a tiny bit (not quite 1%) bit longer than 550mm. The AI in HocusFocus found the back focus with the OEM adapter on the Skywatcher Field Flattener is around 55.8mm. In my case that bit extra BF was perfect since it provided a bit of extra space for adjusting the sensor tilt and fine tuning the backspace adjustment in the process.
Precise Part makes just about any type of custom adapter you might need:
PreciseParts Build-An-Adapter