Can Cassiopeia A (Cas A) be photographed?

15 replies489 views
Helge Büsing avatar
Hello, everyone,

does anyone know if the supernova remnant Cassiopeia A (Cas A) can also be photographed in the visible part of the electromagnetic spectrum or only in the X-ray or radio range?


(Source: Chandra Telescope)
Well Written Engaging
Michael M avatar
Yes, here is a picture taken by Hubble: https://esahubble.org/images/heic0609a/
I belive it is imaged in Ha, Oiii, and Sii but I could be wrong.
Helge Büsing avatar
Yes, here is a picture taken by Hubble: https://esahubble.org/images/heic0609a/
I belive it is imaged in Ha, Oiii, and Sii but I could be wrong.

Interestingly, there is no hit on AstroBin. But a normal focal length seems to be enough...
Michael M avatar
Helge Büsing:
Yes, here is a picture taken by Hubble: https://esahubble.org/images/heic0609a/
I belive it is imaged in Ha, Oiii, and Sii but I could be wrong.

Interestingly, there is no hit on AstroBin. But a normal focal length seems to be enough...

Probably because it's a really challenging target. Here is a picture I found on the Wikipedia page from a 24 inch telescope and it's still really dim. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Cassiopeia_A#Media/File:CassiopeiaA_Supernova_Remnant_Nebula_from_the_Mount_Lemmon_SkyCenter_Schulman_Telescope_courtesy_Adam_Block.jpg
Helge Büsing avatar
Helge Büsing:
Yes, here is a picture taken by Hubble: https://esahubble.org/images/heic0609a/
I belive it is imaged in Ha, Oiii, and Sii but I could be wrong.

Interestingly, there is no hit on AstroBin. But a normal focal length seems to be enough...

Probably because it's a really challenging target. Here is a picture I found on the Wikipedia page from a 24 inch telescope and it's still really dim. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Cassiopeia_A#Media/File:CassiopeiaA_Supernova_Remnant_Nebula_from_the_Mount_Lemmon_SkyCenter_Schulman_Telescope_courtesy_Adam_Block.jpg


That could be a good reason. Perhaps a long exposure is beneficial, as with the Valentine's Rose or the Flying Bat.
However, the nebula seems very attractive.
Luca Marinelli avatar
I actually have about 75 hours of SHO data on Cas A from last season that I haven't processed yet with a 10in f4 telescope. The most challenging channel is Ha, while SII is the brightest. The main structures from the Hubble image are visible but not all the fine tendrils. I'll posting my image in the near future.

Luca
Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging Supportive
Michael M avatar
Luca Marinelli:
I actually have about 75 hours of SHO data on Cas A from last season that I haven't processed yet with a 10in f4 telescope. The most challenging channel is Ha, while SII is the brightest. The main structures from the Hubble image are visible but not all the fine tendrils. I'll posting my image in the near future.

Luca

Can't wait to see it!
Des McMorrow avatar
Interesting question indeed.

Short answer: yes, i accidentally did so!

Please see:

https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/791350-cas-a-nebula-serendipitously-imaged-at-a-fl-of-250mm/

and

https://www.astrobin.com/56qibt/C/

Definitely worth a serious attempt.

Cheers, Des
Helge Büsing avatar
Interesting question indeed.

Short answer: yes, i accidentally did so!

Please see:

https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/791350-cas-a-nebula-serendipitously-imaged-at-a-fl-of-250mm/

and

https://www.astrobin.com/56qibt/C/

Definitely worth a serious attempt.

Cheers, Des

 A very nice close-up, Des!
Luca Marinelli avatar
Interesting question indeed.

Short answer: yes, i accidentally did so!

Please see:

https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/791350-cas-a-nebula-serendipitously-imaged-at-a-fl-of-250mm/

and

https://www.astrobin.com/56qibt/C/

Definitely worth a serious attempt.

Cheers, Des

It's always interesting to me when a deep enough wide-field image shows a number of DSOs in spatial relation to one another. I obviously searched for the position of Cas A but did not realize it's in actual proximity to the Lobster Claw and the bubble nebula. Nice work with your image, Des!

Luca
Well Written Respectful Supportive
Des McMorrow avatar
Thanks, Luca.

Looking forward to seeing your image.

cheers, Des
Well Written Respectful
Victor Van Puyenbroeck avatar
Helge Büsing:

Interestingly, there is no hit on AstroBin. But a normal focal length seems to be enough...

Try searching for "Cas A supernova remnant". This returns mostly images from CTB-1 (another SNR), but also several amateur images of Cas A in the visible spectrum. E.g. these images https://www.astrobin.com/zy8o8y/ and https://www.astrobin.com/pymrak/E/
Helpful
Martin Cibulski avatar
On Youtube it has been recommended by Frank Sackenheim (astrophotocologne) in his last video about photographic  objects visible in Oktober 2022. He presents a picture taken by the Capella 24" observatory in Kreta. It is the last object in this Video in the chapter 'Exoten'.
Luca Marinelli avatar
Here is just a quick snapshot in straight SHO palette of my data with very little processing other than a stretch and a bit of noise reduction. You can see that the Ha signal is tough to pull out but is where you expect it from the Hubble image.

It's also interesting that the inside right arm of the nebula (only a few green dots outlining it) is almost invisible in the narrowband data but quite bright in RGB (I see it in my 2 hours of RGB and is prominent in the images linked by Victor above).

Luca

Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging
Helge Büsing avatar
Victor Van Puyenbroeck:

Try searching for "Cas A supernova remnant". This returns mostly images from CTB-1 (another SNR), but also several amateur images of Cas A in the visible spectrum. E.g. these images https://www.astrobin.com/zy8o8y/ and https://www.astrobin.com/pymrak/E/

Thanks for the tip Victor, very helpful!
Helge Büsing avatar
Luca Marinelli:
Here is just a quick snapshot in straight SHO palette of my data with very little processing other than a stretch and a bit of noise reduction. You can see that the Ha signal is tough to pull out but is where you expect it from the Hubble image.

It's also interesting that the inside right arm of the nebula (only a few green dots outlining it) is almost invisible in the narrowband data but quite bright in RGB (I see it in my 2 hours of RGB and is prominent in the images linked by Victor above).

Luca


Really amazing Luca, a great capture !!