Planetary Imaging with 114mm/4.5" f/8 Reflector - Possible?

3 replies285 views
Mark Germani avatar
Hi folks!

I know most planetary imagers have serious purpose-built setups, but my daughter has a Celestron Powerseeker 114, and I just upgraded my astrophotography mount and can accommodate the weight of her telescope. It's a spherical mirror, but it has pretty decent views of the planets with a 6-15mm eyepiece and 900mm focal length.

I image with a small refractor and have been doing deep sky imaging for a few years now. I don't think there's any point in me doing deep sky imaging with the 114, but I was wondering if it might be possible to use my ASI120MM guide camera to do planetary imaging with it. I checked the FOV in Stellarium and Jupiter and the Galilean moons would fit nicely even without a barlow.

I guess my main questions are:

- Would this venture be advisable or am I just heading for disappointment/frustration? I'm not looking for incredible results here.
- Should I purchase a barlow, and if so, how much magnification should I consider going up to before I max out the resolving ability of the telescope?
- Should I use my ASI120MM with some filters (and if so, which ones?) or should I consider purchasing an inexpensive colour camera?

Thanks in advance for any guidance here!

CS,
Mark
Well Written Respectful Engaging
James Tickner avatar
Short answer - give it a go! I have a small 4” refractor and whilst it doesn’t produce the incredible images you get from large scopes, it nonetheless gives pretty satisfying pictures. It’s a good opportunity to learn about stacking, lucky imaging, sharpening etc. 

To answer your specific questions:

- A 2x Barlow would be helpful. The usual rule of thumb is to image at a focal ratio about 5x your camera pixel size in microns (3.75 um for the ASI120MM). Currently you’re at about F/7.8 and want to be targeting 5 x 3.75 = F/18.75. A 2x Barlow will get you to F/15.6 which is close enough. 
- To produce colour images with your camera you’d need a set of RGB filters (31 mm diameter would be fine) and a filter wheel. You then collect 1-2 min videos using each filter in turn, stack and sharpen and combine to make a colour image. There’s a bit of a learning curve here and you’d also need to use Winjupos to manage the derogation and combination. You’d probably be up for a similar cost to buying a cheap colour camera and the learning curve would be less - might be the easier way to go. 

The Cloudy Nights site has a couple of long-running threads on ‘small bore’ planetary imaging using scopes of 6” or less that will give you a good idea of what you might expect to achieve. The Jupiter thread is https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/398608-small-bore-challenge-jupiter-w-6-or-less
Helpful Engaging Supportive
Mark Germani avatar
Brilliant - thanks @James! Given the focuser is plastic and pretty weak, I'd probably skip the filter wheel and screw the filters in one by one, but maybe an OSC is a better approach after I factor in the cost and effort of LRGB.

I'll check out that thread!

CS,
Mark
Wouter D'hoye avatar
Hi, 

It for sure is possible. within the limitations of the aperture though.. I have a 6 inch which in the end is not that much bigger. The asi 120 is a great camera for lunar/planetary imaging. I'm asolutely positive that especially for lunar you could do some very nice things.

give it a go. You have all the gear.
Related discussions
Hotech Advanced CT Laser Collimator - What is causing this?
Greetings, I purchased the Hotech CT Collimator and have had a difficult time getting good results with it. I have watched the instruction videos multiple times over and I think I understand the concept well, but my collimation still suffers. My use ...
Collimation relevant to spherical mirror telescope maintenance and optimization.
May 2, 2024
678MC or 224MC for Edge 8 HD
Hello all. Later this summer I plan to purchase a planetary setup (with the goal of deep space imaging later on - that is why I am going with the EDGE) and I want to get the right setup. I know about the pixel size x 5 rule. So for the 678MC it would...
Planetary imaging setup discussion directly matches author's planetary imaging interest.
Mar 12, 2024
The Finderscope Is Fixed, But the telescope does not have the same image. What Now?
Hello and welcome. I have a question for everyone. I have aligned the finderscope with the main telescope on my Power Seeker 60az refractor telescope. But even I try to find the right image on the main telescope. I can't seem to determine what th...
Powerseeker telescope troubleshooting relevant to author's daughter's Celestron Powerseeker scope.
Aug 12, 2024
Hello from Schenectady, NY
Hi all, Just getting started on this hobby. Purchased a Celestron Evolution 8, alt az mount. I also have a Celestron StarSense, Focus Motor, .63 focal reducer as well as T-ring and adapter for a Canon EOS 40d. I also have a Revolution Imager 2 system...
Relevant - author imaging planets with similar Celestron equipment and methods.
Nov 5, 2020