Sky-Watcher Esprit 120 ED internal reflection - any thoughts on a remedy?

14 replies979 views
Ian Dixon avatar
Hello all,

My recent two images have been shot at 300 sec light subs, and I am seeing evidence of an internal reflection.

scope: 120 Esprit
flattener: 1.0x stock flattener
camera: 2600mc

Images: https://astrob.in/fn47cv/0/
               https://astrob.in/m9t379/D/

The first image shows a faint red ring that passes through the galaxy in the widefield version.  The second shows a red ring of light that it at the top upper right and is in proximity to the blue star (top right). 

Its annoying. To say the least.

At least I think that the artefact may be generated from an internal reflection - and I am guessing that its sourced from the 1.0x flattener within the 120 esprit, and am at a loss about how to fix it.  My hypothesis is that some IR light is being reflected and the camera is picking it up.   Depending upon the shot the ring of light changes placement in the frame, so likely is an abberation of the combination of the scope, the flattener and the camera.   Some have mentioned that perhaps a luminance filter will fix the problem, however the camera (2600 mc) already comes with a IR/UV cut filter before the sensor.  Thus I am unclear as to whether duplicating this approach will help.  I mean, I could always go ahead and try it, but I thought I should pose the question on the forums first.   

My hope is that some of you may have experienced this issue (or something similar) and have come upon a solution.  At least I hope this question will generate some thoughts.  As I am relatively new to AP, this glitch in my scope's performance is beyond my own experience. 

Thanks for your interest... I would be grateful for any input.

Best

Ian
Helpful Respectful Engaging
andrea tasselli avatar
Maybe they misplaced the window and you got an AR coated one instead (from the Mono series)? Worth checking, IMO.
Ian Dixon avatar
andrea tasselli:
Maybe they misplaced the window and you got an AR coated one instead (from the Mono series)? Worth checking, IMO.

*Hi Andrea,  good suggestion!  I will check it out.
Ian Dixon avatar
Hello all, 

I think I may have solved the issue.  I was looking at my flattener/backspacing arrangement for the 120 esprit and noticed that two of the 10 mm spacers I have used are of a very cheap quality.  I mean they screw together and hold everything properly, but the paint on these two units is glossy.

Holding the assembly to light and peering through it revealed that there was significant reflection being generated by these two spacers.  My plan is to paint them with dull flat black paint and then test to see whether the internal reflections are diminished.

Thanks,

Ian
Well written Helpful Insightful
Ian Dixon avatar
If anyone is interested here is how I fixed the spacers (blackening of the interior).   The glossy paint was on the threads on the interior, now replaced with flat black, an old telescope atm trick.

Ian Dixon avatar
More follow up...(my self generated thread is growing, ha ha). Here is a test of NGC 891, shot in Bortle 2 with a lot of interfering aurora activity.   I can't see any red ringing artifact now - but many of you have sharper eyes... @Thilo ?  @Rodd Dryfoos ?  Have a look and let me know.

This image:  Esprit 120/flattener/AP900 mount/2600mc camera:  1x1, gain 100, 20 x 180 sec, calibrated with flats, testing my fix
 


Thilo avatar
Hi Ian, indeed I can't see on my monitor the red ring artifact that was clearly visible in the other two images of yours. It seems that you have got it! smile Congrats! Best - Thilo
Well written Respectful Supportive
Ian Dixon avatar
Yay!!
John Favalessa avatar
Way to go Ian!  You are a good and persistent sleuth indeed.  -john
Well written Respectful Supportive
Rodd Dryfoos avatar
I can’t see a red ring, but I do see INCREDIBLE detail in the dust band!  Bortle 2 indeed.  The scope and mount  are not bad too, and of course, the astrophotographer is no slouch!   This is a very high end image
Well written Respectful Engaging Supportive
Ian Dixon avatar
John Favalessa:
Way to go Ian!  You are a good and persistent sleuth indeed.  -john

*. Thanks John, I appreciate your input!
Ian Dixon avatar
Ian Dixon avatar
Rodd Dryfoos:
I can’t see a red ring, but I do see INCREDIBLE detail in the dust band!  Bortle 2 indeed.  The scope and mount  are not bad too, and of course, the astrophotographer is no slouch!   This is a very high end image

*                      Thanks Rodd! Much appreciated.  
Rouz Astro avatar
Sometimes painting the shiny parts helps a lot.
The darkest paint I have seen is this one.

CS
Rouz
www.RouzAstro.com


Lamplighter05 avatar
A bit of curve work in photoshop/gimp etc  can help reveal any artefacts ... apologies for messing with your images but its interesting to see those 'hidden' gremlins.

Related discussions
Help With an Image Artifact
Hi All, I'm new to astrophotography and very new to using a HyperStar lens. Imaging train in the photo below is a Celestron EdgeHD 8, HyperStar v. 4 lens, Optolong L-Extreme filter, and an ASI 2600MC-Pro. There's a strange green circle that s...
Internal reflections in scope images similar to green circle issue.
Mar 10, 2021
Newton Flat Problem (Ring pattern) Light pollution a cause?
Hello guys, I've already read a lot of forum post about this topic. Usually the problem apears to be reflections inside the tube, light leaks, sometimes the corrector sticking inside of the tube or a GPU causing wierd stuff. Some people are doing...
Internal reflection causing ring patterns in images; directly addresses your issue.
Mar 13, 2024
0.95x coma corrector internal reflection problems?
Hi all, this coma corrector is also rebranded as Sharpstar 0.95x (or maybe Sharpstar was the original, idk), and probably a few more brand names I was hoping that after I flocked my newt, I would have no internal reflections (there is not a spot that...
Coma corrector internal reflection problems; similar optical reflection issues.
Aug 27, 2024