M51 .. looking for feedback

3 replies300 views
Andy Wray avatar
I'm looking for feedback on the image below.  I know my stars are a weird shape and am trying to work out what is causing them, so ignoring those, what do you make of the rest of the image?


Original:

M51
Tyrel Smith avatar
Hi Andy! It's a nice M51. There is good detail in the galaxy, and you've captured a good amount of dust in the "thumb" area. The one thing that jumps out is a touch of a blue cast to the background in a blotchy sort of pattern. There is some IFN in that area, and it can cause this. You could possible mask the background and reduce the blue and/or saturation, and also lower the background level to help combat this. I like my backgrounds of galaxy images a little darker than my nebula images, at around an RGB/K value of 24 or so, as read out using the Pixinsight probe tool. Maybe ever so slightly bump the contrast to get the orange-yellows in the thumb to come out.

Cheers!

Ty
Well Written Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging Supportive
David Serquera avatar
Hello,
I think is a good picture. I processed mine a couple of days ago and I worked mainly in deconvolution over luminance, the right HDR compression. You could also highlight the H-Alfa regions using color saturation.
Have a look https://astrob.in/tcnryo/0/
sydney avatar
Image looks great on my tablet.  Galaxy seems a bit cyan, so may be more punchy to slightly modify the color balance.  Excellent overall!
Related discussions
[RCC] Heart nebula. First time looking for feedback!
So I've always been more of a lurker of forums than interacting, but I've enjoyed where the astrophotography journey has taken me and would love to know more about how to do more with my images and such. Going to do an info dump below on the ...
Oct 9, 2023
Both posts are requests for feedback and advice on astrophotography images from community members seeking to improve their imaging techniques.