AstroBin is the home of astrophotography - Share full resolution images, preserve acquisition details, discover equipment, discuss techniques, and learn from the community.Discover AstroBin

Lessons learned on finding Abell PN's in Simbad

4 replies165 views
Willem Jan Drijfhout avatar

Under current full-moon conditions, I envisioned that a planetary nebula in narrowband would be a good object to go for. I selected Abell 39 and put that in the target manager of my remotely hosted telescope. The following morning, no images were taken, as the target was apparently not above the horizon.

It turned out that the target I had selected from the Simbad database was not Abell 39, but ACO 39. ACO is a list of galaxy clusters, put together by Abell, Corwin and Olowin in 1989. The list of planetary nebulae put together by Abell in 1966 is identified in the Simbad catalogue as ‘A66’, not ‘Abell’. So the code you’re looking for in Simbad is ‘PN A66 39’.

Another ‘safe’ way to find the Abell PN’s in a catalogue like Simbad is to use the code from the catalogue of Perek and Kohoutek, published in 1969. The naming convention there starts with ‘PK’. Abell 39 for example is PK 047+42.1. In order to do this cross-reference, I found a website from Uwe Glahn, which includes PK-ID’s for all Abell PN objects.

All this is only relevant if your own astroimaging software does not include a dedicated list of Abell PN objects.

Well written Helpful Engaging
TiffsAndAstro avatar

For unusual stuff that Nina doesn't have, I get the Ra and Dec from telescopius.com and paste them into Nina.

Them take an exposure and to check they match up by eye.

Habib Sekha avatar

I feel your pain Willem-Jan, I had the same but then with Abell 78 last year using NINA and Stellarium.

Respectful Supportive
Bob Lockwood avatar

Maybe this can help.

📷 Abell,1.JPGAbell,1.JPG📷 Abell,2.JPGAbell,2.JPG

Mark Theissen avatar

Good post. I’ve also “been there, done that”.