Flats

4 replies74 views
Stephen Jones avatar

Gday all.

Sometimes I use my visual SW 10’ newt to take a photo. If I put my home made hood on and take subframes, should it remain on for flats? My gut says yes but I thought Id give the gurus a yell.

Appreciate your time.

Respectful
Tony Gondola avatar

Yes, the configuration needs to be exactly the same as when you were taking images.

SonnyE avatar

You say a visual Newt.

How are you attaining focus with it in your camera?

There are fundamental differences between visual Newtonians and Astrograph Newtonians.

Mainly the main mirror placement for attaining focus.

https://youtu.be/9d0292TBMHo?si=ce11whsohlcfsPP7&t=1124

But yes, Flats need to be taken as Tony sez, at the same configuration. I take a set of Flats, Darks, and Bias as a library set. Then reuse mine because they are reference images. When I started, I took fresh Flats, Darks, and Bias. But having tried the library method, like so many others use, I prefer it.

Have fun on your adventures in Space!

Helpful Engaging Supportive
Stephen Jones avatar

Gday SonnyE

Mate I say my visual newt because thats what I mainly do with it. I image most of the times with an Askar FRA 500. The newt is a SW 250PDS and its capable of taking photos when I occasionally decide to set it up as its a pain. Its a tad heavy and its on limits on my mount. I changed the focuser, spider vanes, mirror mask and added catseye for better collimation. I use a paracorr but this is not at the correct spacing due to the different focuser…then I put up with a full frame and vignetting. It all comes out in the wash using pixinsight and exterminators. Was curious about flats and the hood. In my previous photos I used the hood but took it off to do the flats and they seem ok. A tad soft due to being way oversampled. Was curious to leave it on as I explained above.

Thanks for the response mate. Ta

Respectful
Stephen Jones avatar

Tony

Thanks for the response mate. Will give it a whirl. Had that feeling it should stay.

Related discussions
How to Make an good astronomical mount with the EQ8-R (or ORION HD110) using Shibumi Astro Kits (long post with photos)
Hi all, This is my first post here. I'm not an English speaker, so I apologize in advance if there are any language errors in the post. There's little practical information online about improving the quality of the Chinese-made EQ8-R. Or Orion HD110 ...
Discusses flat frames for Newtonian telescopes; directly addresses hood usage question.
Mar 10, 2026
Flats
GDay all I have a creek running behind my place and hence lots of trees. I image between them and on my deck. Some nights I can only get ten subs if Im lucky and anything quite high no dramas getting a decent amount. Many times Im lucky for ten. In t...
Directly addresses flat frame procedures and methodology for astrophotography.
Nov 15, 2025