Gary Seven avatar
There is more noise in my images than I would like, and I am wondering if my stretching technique is heavy handed.

What I do now is a series of Levels adjustments, moving the White point leftward until the histogram has enough room for me to make a black point adjustment. This usually takes three iterations, then I add a Curves adjustment.

I am using Affinity Photo, so I looked for Youtube videos on that software.

AstroStace uses iterations of small Gamma adjustments to move the histogram to the right.

James Ritson has a video of a live stream where he uses many gentle Curves iterations to get his stretch.

I also have the JR Macros. I tried one and it worked. But at this point I feel like I am just pushing a button to get a result without understanding the process or learning much from it. So for now, I would like to do this manually.

What techniques should I be using for my initial stretch to keep the noise down?

Or, is the noise just natural to the process and best dealt with later?
Well Written Engaging
Björn Arnold avatar
Hi Gary,

Given that your raw and stacked data is of good quality, there's one important thing if you do whole image processing in Affinity: add some noise reduction. Without noise reduction, you will likely end up with a lot of noise in the background. What you could do in your image processing workflow is to stretch the data to a point where you can clearly distinguish the object against the sky background. Then place a live noise reduction layer right over the pixel layer of your stacked image and increase luminance and color noise reduction. You will only need extremely little (the sliders at 1% can be even too much. You might need to type the numbers like 0.1 for 0.1% and it will show 0% in the input box).

Final noise reduction can be made on the stretched image with higher slider settings.

CS!
Helpful Respectful
Gary Seven avatar
I have been waiting until after stretching before noise reduction. I will try a light pre-emptive strike as you mentioned.
Related discussions
What Could Be Causing This Random Noise All Of A Sudden?
Recently when processing data on several deep sky targets I've been imaging within the course of the last month, I've encountered seemingly unexplainable phenomenon with the stacked data, I am noticing very high levels of noise AFTER stretchi...
Nov 29, 2022
Both posts discuss problems with excessive noise appearing in astrophotography images during the stretching process used in post-processing.
How can you solve this? No DSO In The Stacked Image
Hello and welcome! I would like to reach out to anyone who uses Seastar for astrophotography or knows how to troubleshoot issues related to it. Recently, I started capturing frames of the M101 Pinwheel Galaxy. When I first began imaging this deep sky...
Jan 12, 2025
Both posts are from astrophotographers seeking technical help with image processing and capture issues.
Is this an acceptable noise level?
Hello everyone, I'm looking for a bit of advice on whether or not the level of noise I'm seeing in my images is too much or not. I've recently been going after IC-63 (Ghost of Cassiopeia) and I've tried to push on the Hydrogen-alpha i...
Apr 12, 2025
Both posts are from astrophotographers seeking advice about excessive noise levels in their processed images.
Any secret NR methods? Topaz Denoise? What is your method?
Hello all. know a number of you have had some experience with Topaz - can you tell me how you use it? is the Denoise in Photo AI or the Classic (standalone) version better? I don't think I can get a license for the standalone version because it&#...
Nov 27, 2024
Both posts discuss techniques for reducing noise in astrophotography images.
Tips for Dark Nebula Processing - LRGB
I would love advice/guidance on how to make the best of only one night of shooting LRGB data of a dark nebula in a Bortle 1 sky with some moonlight/noise. The target was Barnard 150 (seahorse nebula) Firstly, I’m sure that having more data would impr...
Sep 19, 2024
Both posts are from astrophotographers seeking advice on reducing noise in their images through better processing techniques.