Good evening, John
To be honest with you, the original image you posted in your first entry is perfect! It’s an inspiration for me and for others to aim for that level until we create something similar or even better.
The problem around here these days is that the system has a human touch, and to make things worse, they know exactly who each photo belongs to when they’re voting.
I don't want to put things this way, but this is how I feel and my personal opinion about the IOTD/TP:
If you’re well-known in the astrophotography community, for example, by winning international contests or even being mentioned in the tough ones; if you’re a YouTuber in the astrophotography community, or even an amateur astrophotographer who makes a new discovery that helps further professional studies, your name will definitely be around the
Top Picks images and sometimes the
IOTD. Because one of the bi-products of that is the number of followers that you acquire on AstroBin.
People can say otherwise and come up with countless justifications to defend their opinions, sometimes claiming a great image isn’t really that good because of this or that (which is never the case and often hypocritical). But at the end of the day, most of those same guys and girls will be there. Sometimes with great images, sometimes with crappy ones and occasionally they’ll throw a bone to the minor leagues just to keep appearances intact.
The tip of the iceberg: go to the
https://app.astrobin.com/explore/astrophotographers-list#image-data and put them by order of the number of followers to the biggest up to the lowest and cross some of those names with google, youtube, facebook and places of that kind of content. You'll see what I mean.
I'm not trying to start a sub discution on this matter, I don't even care about the IOTD/TP and this is my first and only entry about that theme, because I have more to do in life than be in witch hunts. Astrobin for me is just a place to keep my best photos in order, do some research on targets and equipment used, see what some friends are doing around here and nothing more. But sometimes in here, things have too much coincidences that makes a few of us lifting an eyebrow.
Well, like I said above this is just a personal opinion. Regarding the photo, you have a great image there that most of us don't even achive in our wild dreams.
Keep the good work and to the rest of the guys in this entry, I wish you all clear skies, a full bank account to buy more equipment and the time to use it.
Regards,
Cesar