Strange grainy artifacts in background when applying NXT - normal or error?

5 replies94 views
Derek Vasselin avatar

Is this normal or am I doing something wrong? When I apply NXT, I get really strange grainy artifacts in the background. It looks like colored specs all over the image (see below).

Doesn’t appear to matter whether I do NXT early in processing on linear data, or near the end on stretched data. And doesn’t seem to matter if I do more or less NXT (I’ve tried 0.35 up to 0.9 denoising and still get these artifacts). I’ve tried messing around with the Version 3 AI settings as well (HF, LF, intensity, color) and haven’t figured out a solution.

Details (let me know if you need more):

  • Celestron EdgeHD 8

  • ZWO ASI2600MC

  • Optolong L-Enhance HaOiii filter (~18 hours)

  • Altair SiiOiii filter (~28 hrs)

  • Used DBXtract to create Ha, Sii, Oiii and create an SHO image

Is this just an issue with the data or limitation of dual-band imaging? Or is there a specific method to avoid?

📷 image.pngimage.png*Edit: I don’t apply any BXT or NXT until after I combine the 3 channels. Could this also be an issue or should that not matter?

Well Written Engaging
andrea tasselli avatar
That's one of the defects of NXT (V.3). Use sparingly and at maximum iteration (5). Best is to use V.2 to avoid those artifacts.
Derek Vasselin avatar

Ah ok. That explains why I never remember this with V2. Thank you

Quinn Groessl avatar

Yeah I don’t get why RC hasn’t released an update either fixing it or getting rid of AI 3 because there are a ton of people who use it and don’t notice/don’t care/don’t know that it’s leaving a bunch of artifact.

Derek Vasselin avatar

Yeah it’s been driving me crazy for weeks and couldn’t figure out if it was me, a software issue, or a data issue.

Tim Ray avatar

I usually make a smaller preview and run NXT in preview mode while I change HF/LF Pixel Scale slider. Most times this “for me” is 5.5 to 6.0. But keep moving the slider until you get satisfactory results. I have had 4.0 to as high as 8.0. It really depends on the image.

The Denoise sliders for HF and LF color I set to 1.0

The HF Intensity I leave at .9

The LF Intensity I set somewhere between .62 and .82

Russell has a nice description on how to use NXT on his site.

Good Luck and CS

Tim

Helpful