Should I utilize Sii data for Crescent Nebula? If so, what are some good ways.

3 replies146 views
Paul Macias avatar
Hey guys,

Been imaging Crescent Nebula. Originally I started getting Sulfur along with Hydrogen and Oxygen, but looking at the Sulfur, it doesn't look like it's going to add much. I've been trying some custom blends, but none of them look quite as pleasing as standard HOO palette (which is why I suspect HOO is so common for this target). 

Just curious if others would find it worthwhile to add it, and if so, what would be some basic methods to do so? So far I've just been trying different pixel math blends, but nothing seems that great to me. Below is the Sulfur, Hydrogen, and some custom HOO blend with a bit of Sulfur mixed in the red and green channels (I think). 

I do have RGB for the stars, so that shouldn't be a concern here.  Just looking for ideas and thoughts. Thank you in advance!

Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging
Oscar H. avatar
starless recipe:

do HOO (and stretch)

get the SII, stretch, and colorize it golden/orange

screen SII onto HOO

it should look great if you do everything right

OHH also sometimes looks great, depending on the object and how you tweak the palette
Paul Macias avatar
How do you colorize a greyscale image?
Oscar H. avatar
different methods

my personal favorite way is to make a blank image with the same dimensions as your greyscale image (and make the value for this blank image anything above 0)

simply type in something like 0.1 in pixelmath, turn on "create new image", and drag the Process onto your grey nebula image; this will make a new image, a blank dark grey image, with the same dimensions as the nebula image, and with a value of 0.1.

then, bring up Channel Combination, and, if you want a yellow image, for example, you put the nebula image in both the Red and Green channels, but use the blank in the Blue channel

this is simple color mixing logic: Red + Green = Yellow. Start the Channel Combination process.

(for getting a golden colored nebula, I recommend creating a yellow image to start with)

so now, open Background neutralization, make a Preview box in the background of your yellow nebula image, and apply the process

now you should be left with a yellow colored nebula with a dark grey background

all that you need to do now is to change the hue - you can do this with photoshop, or just mess with curves and an inverted luminance mask in PI (or many other ways)



This is my way, I'm not sure how many others do it. Most people just use the NBColourMapper script I think. I find that my method gave better results though.
Related discussions
PixInsight, is it worth it?
First off, I'm not trying to light a fire here, just a fruitful discussion ;) I am currently processing using Siril, Graxpert and Affinity Photo and am happy with those tools. My question is, for over $300.00 US, would switching to PI be worthwhi...
Both posts ask for community advice on whether adopting a new addition or tool would be worthwhile for their astronomy imaging workflow.
Sep 7, 2024
Do I need to add either GIMP or Photoshop for post color processing??
Hey Folks…. So as I make a very slow process of learning PixInsight, and all of the various ways to process my image after stacking.. I find myself geting fustrated at trying to get my images to look as I would like them…. So far I've...
Both posts discuss challenges with processing astronomical images to achieve desired visual results.
Sep 20, 2024
What should I do with my H-II data?
I tried searching the forum for "H-II" but gave up looking after the first 30 hits, or so. So, if this topic has already been covered, please point me to the appropriate thread. With the popularity of OSC cameras has come the advent of dual...
Both posts discuss different approaches to processing narrowband imaging data of emission nebulae, specifically comparing the visual appeal and practicality of different filter combinations and color palettes.
Sep 21, 2024