A tree is growing tall enough to interfere with Three Point Polar Alignment

10 replies1.2k views
AmyWarble avatar
The first two capture points are still fine, but a tree has grown enough to occlude about 1/3 of the final frame. 

I have tried to google this but I just don't understand what I'm reading and how to apply it.  I've found forum posts saying you can polar align almost anywhere in the sky.   My south sky is completely open, no trees, and is where PHD2 wants to point for calibration, anyway.

I don't know if this matters, but my focal length is 840mm and I'm operating in the northern hemisphere.

I'm feeling a little overwhelmed in trying to solve this myself.  Can someone help me? 


Well Written Respectful Engaging
bigCatAstro avatar
AmyWarble:
The first two capture points are still fine, but a tree has grown enough to occlude about 1/3 of the final frame. 

I have tried to google this but I just don't understand what I'm reading and how to apply it.  I've found forum posts saying you can polar align almost anywhere in the sky.   My south sky is completely open, no trees, and is where PHD2 wants to point for calibration, anyway.

I don't know if this matters, but my focal length is 840mm and I'm operating in the northern hemisphere.

I'm feeling a little overwhelmed in trying to solve this myself.  Can someone help me? 



You should be able to select the toggle switch for “Start from current position?” to “on” and that will allow you to run the routine from any star in the part of the sky you’ve pointed to. I do this all the time since Polaris is completely obstructed from my home. I have Stellarium set up to load coordinates to NINA.

i hope this helps!
Helpful Concise
AmyWarble avatar
Really?  That's all I would have to do?

Okay, I will try this.
AmyWarble avatar
That worked!  I can't believe it was that simple.  I think I can figure out how to automate this.  

Thank you so much, big kitty!
Well Written Respectful Supportive
bigCatAstro avatar
AmyWarble:
That worked!  I can't believe it was that simple.  I think I can figure out how to automate this.  

Thank you so much, big kitty!

You’re welcome!  Glad it worked.
Ejo Schrama avatar
AmyWarble:
The first two capture points are still fine, but a tree has grown enough to occlude about 1/3 of the final frame. 

I have tried to google this but I just don't understand what I'm reading and how to apply it.  I've found forum posts saying you can polar align almost anywhere in the sky.   My south sky is completely open, no trees, and is where PHD2 wants to point for calibration, anyway.

I don't know if this matters, but my focal length is 840mm and I'm operating in the northern hemisphere.

I'm feeling a little overwhelmed in trying to solve this myself.  Can someone help me? 



You should be able to select the toggle switch for “Start from current position?” to “on” and that will allow you to run the routine from any star in the part of the sky you’ve pointed to. I do this all the time since Polaris is completely obstructed from my home. I have Stellarium set up to load coordinates to NINA.

i hope this helps!

The solution is to start from the current position and to stop asking your housemates, spouse, etc whether that tree could be trimmed.
AmyWarble avatar
@Ejo Schrama I don't know why you would suggest that I need to "stop asking your housemates, spouse, etc whether that tree could be trimmed."  That comment seems wholly unnecessary when I made no suggestion that trimming the tree was ever being considered.
Well Written
Phil Bordelon avatar
In one of my imaging locations on my very small patio, I have a view of the sky that is clear east to west, but the north-south view is only about 45° wide directly overhead (if that!).  I have better views elsewhere, but it's the only place I can leave my rig unattended for an all night session while I sleep.






TPPA's auto mode (Start from current position - off) might work, but I'm not absolutely sure NINA's choice for points 2 and 3 would be within my very restricted sky view from my patio.

Instead I use Start from current position (I use Alt 40°, Az 276°) with Measure Point Distance set to 10° - 15° and it follows my open sky every time.


Helpful
Médéric Hébert avatar

It’s been a while since I’ve had to mess with it, but if it’s not a temporary problem, you can change it in the pluggins options. This one iircimage.png

Phil Bordelon avatar

Your sky view sounds very much like mine: open horizon to horizon East to West but only 45° (probably less that that) open directly above.

I initially point to AZ 90/ALT 40, set the options just as you noted in your original messageimage.pngBasically goes East to West directly overhead. TPPA runs perfectly every time.

BTW, it’s been very surprising how many nice targets appear in that limited sky view!

Helpful Supportive
Read noise Astrophotography avatar

Call an arborist to trim the tree .