SkyMemo tracker running slow -- add an ASIair autoguider?

4 replies47 views
Rod Van Meter avatar
I'm using a Kenko SkyMemo S tracker, Redcat 51, and Sony a7iii as my primary setup. I'm just now building out my setup; portability matters and my budget is limited, but I'm going piece by piece.

With this load, for the last few sessions, tracking seems to be running about 3% slow (or, possibly, fast). I'm getting star trails of about 3-5 pixels on 30 sec subs, forcing me right now to work with 15 sec subs. This is about 0.5-1.0 arcsec/second of drift, too high.

The drift seems to be entirely R.A., nothing north/south, leading me to suspect it's running slow/fast, rather than alignment. Is that correct? I think I'm pretty good at polar alignment, though there seems to be enough play in the system that I have to tweak it a few times through the night. (Possibly it's me jostling stuff when moving targets.) I'm still not very good at handling my mount on high latitude targets, but the drift seemed to be similar there (Heart & Soul v. Orion), so maybe it actually is alignment rather than running slow?

I've played with balance, significantly over/underweighting it in each direction, doesn't seem to change the behavior. My setup allows me to put the lens/camera assembly pretty close to the polar axis, and I don't think it's overweighted in a strict sense.

I suspected power supply current issues, switched from external USB battery pack to internal, fresh disposable batteries, no change.

So:

1. Any suggestions on diagnosing or fixing? It's only a year old, but I'm thinking about disassembling & cleaning. Is that likely to help?
2. I'm planning to make my next purchase an ASIair Pro controller. I assume that with guiding it will be able to compensate?
3. If I'm reading the sellers' websites right, the controller itself is in stock, but the recommended accompanying small guidescope or camera is out of stock with no ETA for when they will be available. Any recommendations for a substitute?
Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging
andrea tasselli avatar
1. No.
2. Yes.
3. Any camera that goes into the ASIair, e.g. ASI120MM mini. Any 30mm aperture guiding scope would do at your pixel scale. A IR Cut filter is recommended.
Rod Van Meter avatar
Thanks for the advice!
IR Cut filter for my imaging camera? I thought the preferred thing to do was to remove the in-camera IR filter as an astromod, in order to improve the long-wavelength response? (I haven't posted about it here yet, but I *am* having trouble with a gradient across the sensor I haven't been able to get rid of yet; the darks & biases seem to reduce it but not enough. Fundamentally, I need longer subs.)
Engaging Supportive
andrea tasselli avatar
The IR Cut is for the guiding camera, not the DSLR. As for gradient across the sensor you'd need flats to address those and then the residual non-flatness (e.g. coming from shooting with some/a lot of light pollution) addressed in post-processing.
Helpful Concise
Rod Van Meter avatar
Re: IR Cut, got it, thanks, I misunderstood.

I'm using flats, of course, and also darks and biases. I just posted more about this over under Processing [Deep Sky].
Related discussions
DIY Power using the EGO tool battery
Here is a partial posting from an image posting I posted recently regarding a grab and go imaging rig. The hope is to reach a wider number of potentially interested people. I did search the site and even CN to see if there was anything like this and ...
DIY Power using the EGO tool battery — Not directly relevant to tracking drift issues.
Jul 2, 2023
Fornax LT2 Review
I love this tracker Background: I rapidly progressed from a full frame DSLR wide angle on tripod, to an Omegon tracker, to a Skywatcher tracker, to a Fornax tracker and Vixen SXD2 mount I bought the LT2 after banging my head against a wall in trying ...
Fornax LT2 Review — Relevant tracker alternative; addresses similar tracking performance concerns.
Jul 1, 2023
star adventurer gti home position and polar align woes
hi everyone, been here for a while now and it's been great inching forward in learning this hobby! I've recently bought myself a Star Adventurer GTi mount and have been using it for a while. however, it;s been pretty difficult (as a consequen...
star adventurer gti home position and polar align woes — Relevant; polar alignment affects tracking accuracy and drift.
Oct 31, 2023
Speeding up Polar Alignment NINA/PhD2
I routinely struggle to quickly polar align my EQ6 Pro mount quickly and I have used a variety of methods including NINA 3 point and Drift alignment in PhD2. I should add, I'm in the southern hemisphere and my view of the pole is obscured. I susp...
Speeding up Polar Alignment NINA/PhD2 — Relevant; drift alignment directly addresses tracking drift problems.
May 22, 2023
Getting started with a small mount.
Hi Everyone, I've taken a few images now and i am enjoying it. I'm not yet ready to buy a telescope, but I am ready to buy a small portable astrophotography setup. I am thinking of the following iOptron SkyGuider ProZWO ASI290MM Mini CameraZW...
Discusses portable tracker setup with autoguiding similar to author's planned configuration.
May 25, 2020