ZWO EAF doesn't return to correct position - Forums

Topic starter

Mar 25, 2025

I am having an issue with my ZWO EAF on my Apertura Carbonstar RC6. The focuser doesn't return to the same position when moving. I noticed this in nina as my focus point keeps getting a lower step position than the time before.

To try and fix, I open the ZWO EAF driver, moved the focuser all the way and set the position to zero. Then moved to my normal focus position, which is about position 11000. that is at the 1" spot on my actual focuser. I then moved the focuser via the driver to 13000 and back to the original 11000. However, it doesn't return to the same spot. It is always about 200-300 focuser steps short. So I need to use the driver and move a the focuser in about 200-300 steps to get back to the correct position.

I have tried calculating backlash and putting that number in the driver with no success (i got the same result). I tried several backlash numbers between 100-255 and got the same result. Can you help? is my eaf defective?

Richard

Mar 25, 2025

Definitely start with watching the below tutorial by Patriot Astro and remember to set backlash compensation to Overshoot and not Absolute. You only need to put backlash compensation in one direction (ie IN or OUT) and not both, so adjust one and keep the other set to 0.

https://youtu.be/lHrfaR7A0L0

Helpful Concise

Brian Puhl

IOTD Staff

Mar 25, 2025

Your EAF is slipping.

The grub screws on the collet are likely not tight enough. If that doesn't work, check to make sure the friction is tight enough on your focuser.

Well Written Concise

Keith Geissler

Topic starter

Mar 25, 2025 · Edited: Mar 25, 2025

Brian Puhl:
Your EAF is slipping.

The grub screws on the collet are likely not tight enough. If that doesn't work, check to make sure the friction is tight enough on your focuser.

I have the grub screws as tight as i can get them and the friction knob is also quite tight. I also took the EAF off to make sure I could turn the focuser manually. That worked and I reattached the focuser. It is always about 200-300 steps off on the return.

Rick Krejci

Frequent contributor

Mar 25, 2025

Maybe there is some slipping of the connection between your scope and EAF. I wouldn't mess with the backlash setting in the EAF driver (in the EAF equipment "gear" setting) if that's where you are putting those numbers in. Leave that one at 0 (or at least no more than 30-40) and just use Nina's Overshoot compensation method and use like 300-400 on one direction only.

Helpful Concise

Keith Geissler

Topic starter

Mar 25, 2025

Rick Krejci:
Maybe there is some slipping of the connection between your scope and EAF. I wouldn't mess with the backlash setting in the EAF driver (in the EAF equipment "gear" setting) if that's where you are putting those numbers in. Leave that one at 0 (or at least no more than 30-40) and just use Nina's Overshoot compensation method and use like 300-400 on one direction only.

Is there anyway to test the overshoot setting without doing an autofocus?

Rick Krejci

Frequent contributor

Mar 25, 2025

Keith Geissler:
Rick Krejci:
Maybe there is some slipping of the connection between your scope and EAF. I wouldn't mess with the backlash setting in the EAF driver (in the EAF equipment "gear" setting) if that's where you are putting those numbers in. Leave that one at 0 (or at least no more than 30-40) and just use Nina's Overshoot compensation method and use like 300-400 on one direction only.

Is there anyway to test the overshoot setting without doing an autofocus?

I just needs to be a number way above (like double or more) what you think the backlash is. It doesn't matter as long as it washes out the backlash. Just don't have it fight the driver "gear" backlash setting which is why I suggest setting that to 0.

I generally figure out my approximate backlash by observing the fine focus know when I reverse direction (with no backlash compensation set anywhere). Once the knob starts moving, that's about your backlash. Then overshoot by a lot more than that (at least double, I do 3-4x) and you're good.

You can try backing down on it during a session until you see the curve look wonky (flat on one side), but it's easier just to leave it a large value if it works.

Helpful

Keith Geissler

Topic starter

Mar 25, 2025

I think I may have found the issue. Right around the focus point of my focuser. I noticed it would stick as it tried to rack in. I found the snag and it seems to be working now. I will test more when I can auto focus a few times

Brian Puhl

IOTD Staff

Mar 25, 2025

Sounds like a winner to me. If it was a backlash issue, you'd simply miss focus point, but the focus point shouldn't be shifting like you were seeing. Do you think the snag was it skipping a tooth maybe?

Keith Geissler

Topic starter

Mar 25, 2025 · Edited: Mar 25, 2025

Brian Puhl:
Sounds like a winner to me. If it was a backlash issue, you'd simply miss focus point, but the focus point shouldn't be shifting like you were seeing. Do you think the snag was it skipping a tooth maybe?

not sure what it was. I removed the eaf, and manually turned the focus knob and it still stuck. I removed the focuser from the scope and it worked fine. I put it back on and it still appears to work. Go figure.

Related discussions

External focuser on an SCT; What about temperature change induced focal shift and back-focus?

It seems like every serious astro-photographer is putting external focusers on the back of the EdgeHD telescopes and locking the mirrors. I picked up a nice little EdgeHD 8" and a Primaluce Lab Esatto 2" LP focuser and gave it a try myself....

ZWO EAF external focuser issues; similar telescope and positioning problems.

15 days ago

APT 3.80 and ZWO EAF Ascom Update

Hello fellows, I'm in need of help. Today I discovered that ZWO realese an update that can push the EAF focuser from the default maximum steps 65000 up to 600000 steps. That sounds great since I had that problem / situation with my SCT regarding ...

ZWO EAF positioning issue after firmware/driver update similar to yours.

Oct 20, 2023

NINA and EAF - keeps resetting zero position

Hi, I was hoping someone knows a solution to the following issue I am having: I recently put together a new rig; which includes a ZWO EAF motor focus and runs on NINA 2.1. When I initially set up all the equipment in NINA, I had the focuser in its &q...

ZWO EAF position tracking issue similar to yours with focus point retention.

Apr 18, 2023

Question about multiple EAFs/PCs

I have been putting together my second setup, and I think (finally) after 6 months I have everything. The last piece of the puzzle being my second EAF. My question is, if I switch PCs do the EAF's settings stay? Today I set the zero position and ...

Directly addresses EAF position memory and settings persistence issues.

Nov 30, 2023

EdgeHD 8 Focus Point Moving

Hello! Curious if anyone can assist here. I have an EdgeHD 8 using a ZWO EAF. Been using it fine for well over 2 years now and everything has been fine until recently. It can’t seem to find focus anymore using Nina/Hocus Focus. What happens is the fo...

ZWO EAF focus point moving problem; directly addresses same equipment malfunction.

24 days ago