Back to forums

[RCC] Leo Triplet in HaLRGB

Russell Croman Astrophotography NoiseXTerminator Russell Croman Astrophotography BlurXTerminator Russell Croman Astrophotography StarXTerminator Processing Request for feedback
4 replies•431 views
James Markgraf avatar
James Markgraf avatar
I'm just getting started with mono imaging and the processing that goes into it and would appreciate feedback.

Process:
  • Stack and align with WBPP
  • Graxpert
  • StarXTerminator to remove the stars
  • Clone stamp to clean up the one dust mote that no amount of flats seems to remove (I've gotta pull my camera to clean the sensor window)
  • Pixel math to bring the stars back in
  • Channel combination to create the RGB image
  • Background normalization
  • Color calibration
  • BlurXTerminator
  • StarXTerminator on Ha and RGB
  • SetiAstro's Continuum Subtraction script for Ha
  • SetiAstro's Star Stretch script on the stars only image
  • SetiAstro's Statistical Stretch script on the starless images
  • Curves transformation on RGB
  • Curves transformation on Ha
  • Curves transformation on Lum
  • LRGB combination to add L to RGB
  • Combine H-Alpha script to bring the Ha in to RGB
  • Some more curves to address the background a little bit
  • HLP's Stars Back script to bring the stars back in
  • NoiseXTerminator to clean up
  • SetiAstro's signature add script (forget the name off the top of my head)
  • GIMP to shrink the image down a little from its original size (96 MP after drizzle integration!)


This workflow is based on a SetiAstro YouTube video that I found works well for me. I know I could use SPCC instead of Color Calibration but I had some funky issues with getting the astrometric solution on my image, so I skipped that for now. I also know I'm using a lot of scripts instead of using the processes behind them, but, aside from Continuum Subtraction, I could replace most scripts with the underlying processes if the scripts went away.

Helpful
Scott Stirling avatar
Scott Stirling avatar
After drizzle integration it is I think normal to resample the resulting image back to its original dimensions, which reveals its improvement on factors such as FWHM, noise and Eccentricity.

Looks good.  There’s a lot more data to be captured there because that area has a lot more stars and IFN and a long tail of stars or dust on the “Hamburger Galaxy.”   Keep at it — Leo is near zenith at a reasonable hour this time of year, get more data and show us how it comes out.
Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging Supportive
Rabeea Alkuwari avatar
Rabeea Alkuwari avatar
Things that can improve your image:

1. replace LRGB combination with Imageblend script - this way u will have more control on luminance/color blend
2. SPCC, if you have issues applying it i always apply SPCC pre strech and it always seem to work
3. learn GHS to stretch ur images - it will give you more control on what u want to display in terms of signal. Displaying hamburger galaxy’s tail is a bit challenging but to me it was only achievable using GHS
4. HDRMT post stretch (on lum image) can show lots of detail on galaxies- make sure u have lum mask option on and play with layers to your taste
Helpful
James Markgraf avatar
James Markgraf avatar
Scott Stirling:
There’s a lot more data to be captured there because that area has a lot more stars and IFN and a long tail of stars or dust on the “Hamburger Galaxy.”   Keep at it — Leo is near zenith at a reasonable hour this time of year, get more data and show us how it comes out.


I actually got some more lights the other night, so I'm going to try to up my total exposure time and see what I get. Being so close to Philadelphia, light pollution in my area is HORRIBLE. I'm on the verge of being Bortle 9, so I try to keep my exposures relatively short and just take as many as I possibly can.

I'll try resampling after everything is said and done and see how it looks. Thanks for the input.
Well Written
James Markgraf avatar
James Markgraf avatar
Rabeea Alkuwari:
Things that can improve your image:

1. replace LRGB combination with Imageblend script - this way u will have more control on luminance/color blend
2. SPCC, if you have issues applying it i always apply SPCC pre strech and it always seem to work
3. learn GHS to stretch ur images - it will give you more control on what u want to display in terms of signal. Displaying hamburger galaxy’s tail is a bit challenging but to me it was only achievable using GHS
4. HDRMT post stretch (on lum image) can show lots of detail on galaxies- make sure u have lum mask option on and play with layers to your taste

I'll have to check out the ImageBlend script. I never even thought to look to see if there was one available. I skipped SPCC at the time of this image because I had some issues with plate solving the image. I think that perhaps there was an issue with my GAIA catalog because I reloaded a fresh copy and my solving is working again, so I'll definitely give SPCC another shot. I've been playing around with GHS a bit but still not quite there in terms of comfort level (I seem to have a heavy hand sometimes). I have not played around with HDRMT so I'll definitely give that a go.

I am going to re-stack my images since I have more lights to add. I'll incorporate your suggestions into the process and see how it goes. Thanks for the input.
Well Written Respectful Supportive
Related discussions
[RCC]M45
Greetings! I've been practicing astronomy for a little over 3 years now and imaging for about 2 of those years seriously. I'm a fairly new user of PixInsight and am learning as much as I can, and there is still a ton to know. I'm also ver...
Jan 4, 2024
Both posts are from astronomy enthusiasts seeking feedback and learning opportunities as they develop their astrophotography and image processing skills.
[RCC] 1.5 hours of Rosette Nebula
Request you to help critique the processing technique and final output of the image. Posting the starless version as I am particularly concerned that there is a lot of "scratches" or scratchiness in the image especially in the dark areas. M...
Aug 26, 2024
Both posts are requests from astrophotographers seeking feedback and critique on their image processing techniques.
[RCC] Help me improve my landscape astrophotography processing
Hi, since last summer, I have started doing landscape astrophotography more seriously and bought a new setup for this discipline. It consists of: Camera: Canon EOS 200da Lens: Samyang 12mm F/2.8 A stable tripod from SmallRig and a solid powerbank I a...
Mar 13, 2025
Both posts are from beginners seeking advice or sharing their approach to astrophotography techniques and equipment.
[RCC] Soul Nebula: Where is my OIII?
Hello everyone. I recently purchased my first dedicated astronomical camera (Playerone Ares-C) and am finally starting to get some data that can be considered as such. After a few short acquisition tests, I finally managed to acquire a substantial da...
Nov 3, 2024
Both posts are from beginners in astrophotography seeking advice and feedback on their imaging techniques and results.