Star halos projected in different directions

3 replies144 views
James Malone avatar
When using my RASA 8, I sometimes notice bright stars have a projection to one side. I thought maybe it was mirror tilt, but the projections are on opposite sides in the same photograph. For example here are stars from the left and right sides of the same image, respectively.



So I can learn and improve my skills, I wanted to ask - what causes something like this?

Thank you!
Well Written Respectful Engaging
rhedden avatar
I get similar problems with my C11, and the longer the subs are, the worse the distortions get.  The reason in my case is that the exposures are way too long for the bright stars.  The brightest stars are saturated in a few seconds, and the rest of the exposure is integrating the halo that you don't even want to see.  Any internal reflecting surface in your imaging train can cause spikes, offset halos, etc. 

One solution is to avoid positioning bright stars near a corner or edge, if possible.  Another option is to take a separate set of exposures of very short duration, and use them to replace the "burned out" stars.  However, perhaps the best solution is to shoot some narrowband frames and use them as the luminance channel for your stars.  I'm assuming you're using an OSC camera with your RASA, but there are narrowband filters that can be put in front of the camera to shoot a grayscale image.  With my C11, the stars are so much smaller with narrowband filters that it's quite shocking.
Well Written Helpful Insightful Engaging
James Malone avatar
I get similar problems with my C11, and the longer the subs are, the worse the distortions get.  The reason in my case is that the exposures are way too long for the bright stars.  The brightest stars are saturated in a few seconds, and the rest of the exposure is integrating the halo that you don't even want to see.  Any internal reflecting surface in your imaging train can cause spikes, offset halos, etc. 

One solution is to avoid positioning bright stars near a corner or edge, if possible.  Another option is to take a separate set of exposures of very short duration, and use them to replace the "burned out" stars.  However, perhaps the best solution is to shoot some narrowband frames and use them as the luminance channel for your stars.  I'm assuming you're using an OSC camera with your RASA, but there are narrowband filters that can be put in front of the camera to shoot a grayscale image.  With my C11, the stars are so much smaller with narrowband filters that it's quite shocking.

Awesome, thank you!

I suspected that might also be a problem - I’m using 120sec exposures which is probably way too long. I realized last night that the stars are all blown in my subs (near 1 in PI.) I’ll dial back the exposures once the clouds here end in Seattle.
Well Written Respectful
andrea tasselli avatar
Marginal rays are always clipped in commercial SCs otherwise you'd need a much larger primary. That's what you see in those stars. The option is always to shot well below the threshold for saturation and implement an erosion mask or something similar, IMHO.
Related discussions
Tilt!
Hi folks: I seem to have a bit of a nasty tilt issue that has crept up on me. I've never had perfect stars in all corners but the coma was pretty minimal so I didn't let it bother me. In the last 9 months it's become much worse, though, t...
Discusses tilt issues affecting stars across image field.
Aug 19, 2023
Star Halos and star "+"?
Hello everybody so last night i decided to shoot the Ghost Nebula and Iris Nebula in one frame wiht my redcat 51 and Asi183MC Pro. Now, i only got a little above an hour of integration time but i wanted to ask, is this wierd + artifact that i see on ...
Addresses star halos and optical aberrations in imaging.
Oct 14, 2023
Problem with coma corrector Baader MPCC Mark III and GSO Newton 200/800 F4
Hello community from Astrobin: I have a question that I hope you can answer. Recently I bought a Newtonian reflector (GSO 200/800 F4) and before that I had a coma corrector Baader MPCC Mark III. I run a test to see if there is any problem with the eq...
Covers optical problems with reflector telescopes and correctors.
Feb 17, 2023
Intra-star color problem...
I use and ASI183mc which I like very much for the most part… However, I have a problem from time to time where when I process an image, there is a color gradient within the brighter stars. In these cases, the star might be nice and round but on...
Star halos and projections may indicate optical misalignment causing color fringing.
Jan 22, 2020