Diffraction starburst around bright stars - Sharpstar 15028 HNT f/2.8

4 replies223 views
codwyer avatar
Fine tuning a new acquisition, the TS Hypergraph 6 version of the Sharpstar 15028 HNT. All is good, I like it a lot, but have quite an annoying problem with starburst diffraction.

The image below shows two main problems
(1) The starburst itself (could live with it)
(2) Fading of the starburst on stars towards the edge of the frame, which seem to follow the vignetting profile of the scope (the vignetting is slightly off centre also).

Ordinarily, given it is symmetric in the centre, I don't really mind the starburst, but cannot deal with it being partially present on stars all around the edges and between the edges and centre.

This scope has a lot of shiny screws that were not blackened (I wish TS would do this, but maybe have an agreement with Sharpstar not to modify scopes?)

As there are no feature impeding on the aperture of the primary mirror, I must conclude this diffraction is caused before the light hits the primary mirror.
Here is what I see looking into the scope, many screws. 


I don't see this effect on images produced by this scope elsewhere, so wondering what peoples thought are, especially if you have one. 

This occurs even when the spacing and stars are in good shape beyond where the asymmetry in stars is seen.

Any help or insight appreciated, especially since the same screw density/location does not seem to do this to other people as far as I can tell.

CS, Colm
codwyer avatar
Image quality after posting is very poor, so please check the perseus double cluster on the astrobin profile to see the starburst effect properly/clearly.
andrea tasselli avatar
It ain't no shiny screws or similar. It is just the way marginal rays are clipped at the very edge of the frame by the complex optical system you've got. Learn to live with it is my best advice. Personally I don't find them objectionable. Otherwise get a significantly out-of-focus star imaged from edge to centre and diagonally across and see what the clipping looks like. There might give some insight on how to correct it, e.g. by moving the corrector optics in or out. If indeed is correctable…
codwyer avatar
andrea tasselli:
It ain't no shiny screws or similar. It is just the way marginal rays are clipped at the very edge of the frame by the complex optical system you've got. Learn to live with it is my best advice. Personally I don't find them objectionable. Otherwise get a significantly out-of-focus star imaged from edge to centre and diagonally across and see what the clipping looks like. There might give some insight on how to correct it, e.g. by moving the corrector optics in or out. If indeed is correctable...

Thanks Andrea,
With correct spacing, I was hoping a contributory reason would not be the corrector position and overall working distance. It can be modified by changing the position of the stop ring in the draw tube where the corrector screws into.
I like the 'starburst' too, dislike half starburst primarily because it appears in shape like extreme coma due to this clipping effect.  Suggestion on the star test across frame is a good idea.
I might investigated whether the stop ring for the corrector depth in the focuser drawtube contribute to vignetting or clipping also. Difficulty (or really worry) is being able to correctly mark exactly where it is right now before moving it, until I get a longer vernier calipers.
codwyer avatar
I cam across this query I made by accident just now, so thought to close it out for anyone who sees it. 
In this case, it was a turned down edge, completely fixed with a printed mirror mask that is placed on the existing mirror mask or the original cell. Coated with fine black velour, stars are perfect.
Related discussions
Imaging near bright stars
I've taken a couple of images of the Horsehead Nebula, and I get a bright blue spike intruding on the image from nearby Alnitak (see this image for example: The Horsehead Nebula - B33). I see plenty of other similarly framed images that don'...
Diffraction spikes around bright stars directly relevant to Alnitak spike issue.
Nov 25, 2019