Low amperage risk for cooled cameras

9 replies207 views
Pablo Petit avatar
Hello

I was wondering if there is a risk to use a cooled camera with a power supply that has the right voltage but a lower amperage than required.

In my case I have a QHY294M that uses about  3 Amps when the cooling is at 100%. 
At 100%, the camera cools about 35°C below ambient, but because the power consumption grows with the square of the temperature difference,
it only needs 25% power to reach half of the maximum cooling or about 0.75 Amps for 17°C below ambient (I've tested that).

So my plan would be to use a portable 5v/2.1A batterie that are really common, cheap and realiable and a 5 to 12v converter that will give me a 
12v/0.875A (minus the conversion loses) power supply to get about 15°C below ambient which is sufficient in my opinion for portable imaging.

Does anyone know if doing that can in any way damage the camera or have other negatives effects ?

Clear Skies
Helpful Engaging
Christian Großmann avatar
Hi Pablo,

 I guess with 5V/2.1A battery you mean a small power supply?

There are some things that could happen. I try to explain it in a short way. This is by far not a complete description…

The power supply for digital devices is key. Your camera needs 3 Amps as average current , if you run it at 12V and with 100% of cooling power. You could run it with less current, but there are some things that could happen.

Digital devices are basically little computers with one or more microcontrollers in it. They consist of thousands of transistors, that switches all the time. While they switch, they need a good amount of current for a short while. When you measure the current you are usually not measuring those peaks, but you are measuring the average current. Those are different things. If you draw more current than the power supply can handle, the voltage drops and you are not working with 12V anymore. This may have different effects.

At first, your power supply will probably heat up and in the worst case will be destroyed.

The second case could be, that your camera will not work safely. The voltage drop or the missing current can lead to errors while you are working with them. They may disconnect, deliver bad data or may not working well for other reasons. But the real issue is always a bad power supply. It is hard to detect the reason for those problems, because nobody thinks about the power in the first place.

With 5V and 2.1 Amps, the power supply can deliver about 10 Watts of power. Your camera needs with 12V and 3 Amps already 36W of power (worst case). No matter what you do, you will not get more than 10 Watts out of the used power brick. If your 12V converter is used, you loose something (mostly about 5 to 10% or more). But your Step-Up-Converter is made for only 0,875A. If you draw more current, the voltage will drop and your camera may probably not work correctly. Also the converter gets usually really hot if you even use it at the maximum possible current. Don't trust that value if it is a cheap converter!

As conclusion, I wont suggest a solution with such a drastic difference in values. It can work, but it surely is not reliable. If things go really bad, you can destroy your camera. I think, a 12V/3A power supply isn't that expensive. You can get them for under 10 Bucks.

If I misunderstood your question and you really want to use a battery, than this is another topic. Then we have to talk about other parameters like Amps per hour and how much current the battery can deliver or how long you plan to run your device.

I would suggest to buy a decent power supply. It really can be a small investment. If you are going the battery route, than do some more research and be careful. There are a lot of things that can go wrong. If you do not have much knowledge about electricity, than better ask for help and don't do it yourself!

I hope, this answer helps in any way.

Clear skies…

Christian
Helpful
dkamen avatar
However, the TEC cooler and the camera draw power independently: TEC from the power supply, camera from USB.

So the discussion about what circuit gets damaged or malfunction applies only to the cooler. I believe it will work okay with reduced power input (it is a rather simple electronic circuit quite unlike the camera) except perhaps 25% performance might not be adequate. Also even though the camera is independent from the cooler, it might check wether the cooler has sufficient power and refuse to function. 

I would ask QHY support.

Cheers,

D.
Helpful Concise
Christian Großmann avatar
However, the TEC cooler and the camera draw power independently: TEC from the power supply, camera from USB.

So the discussion about what circuit gets damaged or malfunction applies only to the cooler. I believe it will work okay with reduced power input (it is a rather simple electronic circuit quite unlike the camera) except perhaps 25% performance might not be adequate. Also even though the camera is independent from the cooler, it might check wether the cooler has sufficient power and refuse to function. 

I would ask QHY support.

Cheers,

D.

OK, thats a good point I forgot about. Sorry. I am powering the camera (via an external USB hub) and the cooler from the same power supply. So for me there might be those problems. 

Thanks for the kindly reminder...
Minh Lết avatar
Nope. Never under power your gear. If you ever see a computer power supply bursting in flame due to under wattage then you'd never think about under power your device again. 
It may work. But just a few minutes the cooler set to 100% can have catatrophic consequences (on my camera the cooler always  set to 100% everytime it plugged in until the sensor reach 0*C).
John Sim avatar
I don't think you need to run the camera so cold. If you look at the product page for the 294 on the QHY website, they show a graph of dark current vs temperature and it is quite flat up to around zero or even +5 degrees. The important think is to use temperature matched darks but read noise is more significant than dark current noise.
Helpful Insightful Respectful
Christian Großmann avatar
@minhlead hits another good point here.

The power draw of 25% (in your case) is reached not until some time. It is reached if the target temperature is close to the value you investigated. During power up and setting the target temperature you will need more than that.
Mo Tabbara avatar
The TEC itself won't get damaged - the temperature differential it can generate is proportional to the current through it so you'll limit how much you can cool. The main but rare failure mode in the setup is going to be a voltage drop across a FET, particularly a power FET that might be found in a switched-mode power supply leading to a "latch-up". Those FETs might get destroyed if they latch up due to a low-voltage situation. It would be a particularly amateurish circuit to not include under and over-voltage protection and discrete components like the image sensor itself, TEC controller and the USB transceiver generally have their own internal latch-up protection. If something is going to burn, it will likely be the step-up convertor due to latch-up.
Well Written Helpful Insightful
Pablo Petit avatar
Thank you all for your responses.
I didn't expected that much.

Yes I should have precised that this would only power the TEC, and that it is possible to manually set TEC power to obtain a desired temperature without never using 100% power (Sharpcap for instance allows that)

But in any case, I am now conviced that this is not a good idea, I'll put more budget and find a decent power bank.

About that, do you have any advice ? What do you use to power your equipement for a long (8h+) night outside ? 
I've looked at some "astro" power banks and it rapidly comes to hundreds of euros.

Thanks
Tommy Blomqvist avatar
Pablo Petit:
Thank you all for your responses.
I didn't expected that much.

Yes I should have precised that this would only power the TEC, and that it is possible to manually set TEC power to obtain a desired temperature without never using 100% power (Sharpcap for instance allows that)

But in any case, I am now conviced that this is not a good idea, I'll put more budget and find a decent power bank.

About that, do you have any advice ? What do you use to power your equipement for a long (8h+) night outside ? 
I've looked at some "astro" power banks and it rapidly comes to hundreds of euros.

Thanks

You could use a standard leisure battery (70-120Ah) and drain it to 75% without any problems - that's more than just one night
But you will need to charge it before and after.
You should also charge it every second month or so even if you are not using it.
This is also the case with cheaper "astro" power banks with lead-batteries.

I have used smaller 12V batteries for UPS and emergency lighting (7, 14 and 17 Ah) and they have worked well for me and my rig.
Just place them in a plastic toolbox or similar and mount a couple of 12V sockets.
Could add powerswitch and volt/amp meter...
( After a while I realised that my homemade frankenstein-power-supply had cost more than even better "astro" power bank... )

I do recommend that you sooner or later invest in a solution with better battery technology.
They don't drop voltage when stored (and used) and they are much lighter.
Helpful Engaging