Refractor collimation question

4 replies112 views
Sean Mc avatar
When i defocus, the center of the defocused stars are all shifted in the same direction across the field. If the primary cell was out of collimation, would the center of defocused stars be radially off center around the field? 

Or is this tilt?  The primary cell does have collimation and locking screws. My camera/filter wheel do not have tilt, as they work just fine on my other two scopes. 

thx in advance!
ScottF avatar
If the two circles are not concentric, with the center one off-center, then collimation is off.
Well Written
andrea tasselli avatar
It's tilt.
Tony Gondola avatar
If you can put an ocular on your scope you'll be able to check this visually and eliminate the camera as a cause. If you still see off-center donuts when out of focus, it's collimation. Also, if your camera had significant tilt it's likely to show up with all your scopes. I vote collimation.
Well Written Helpful Respectful Concise
Sean Mc avatar
The direction of the “tilt” or “miscollimation” rotates around as I rotate the camera. It has to be somewhere upstream of the filter wheel. 

There is no play in the focuser, and the stars don’t change when I tighten or loosen the lock screw on the rotator. 

I have not really used this scope before, but I did whack it on a wall corner when bringing it up from the basement lol. Stupid crazy german shepherd is to blame for that.
Related discussions
RC8 Collimation using Innovations Foresight SkyWave
Hi, I will soon resume AP using my GSO RC8, that hasn't been used for 2 years and travelled a bit by car in between. Last time I checked it wasn't collimated anymore. I doubt it will be when I'll get it out of retirement (never works that...
Both posts seek advice about collimating their telescopes to resolve optical alignment issues affecting their astrophotography.
Aug 26, 2024
Shifting primary mirror
Hi All I hope that you have some experience that can help me here. When I image low on the horizon, my stars are not good📷 image.png Near Zenith - same star. 📷 image.png Yesterday I realised that my Primary mirror shifted - and that most likely was t...
Both posts describe optical alignment issues affecting star quality in telescope imaging, seeking advice on diagnosing collimation or tilt problems.
Mar 6, 2026
Newt Astigmatism: tilt or secondary mirror?
Hello, I'm struggling to get good star shapes across images from my ONTC 10" F4, specifically around the corners. I tried everything and can't seem to locate/confirm the source of my problems. Some information about the setup: General Se...
Both posts describe optical alignment issues affecting star quality across their telescope's field of view.
May 24, 2024
Custom M54 tilt adapter to suit QHY CFW3M-SR & OAG-M system, fits within 55mm BF - Design Files Included!
Hello all. I have a QHY 294M-Pro, CFW3M-SR, and OAG-M fitted to my Vixen R200SS newt. I have been battling tilt with my 294M ever since I bought it, and have been stumped by the lack of suitable tilt adjusters available on the market (especially in M...
Both posts discuss troubleshooting optical alignment issues (collimation and tilt) in Newtonian reflector telescopes with modern imaging equipment.
Jan 1, 2025