[RCC] Critique requested for IC 405 the "Flaming Star"

3 replies237 views
HR_Maurer avatar
Hi everyone,
i want to request critique for my latest image of IC 405.

The thing i want to address: The stars.
I took my telescope to the observatory, and due to transport, some misadjustment in the telescope occured. I also got some issues with either astigmatism (the main mirror is glued), or with some kind of tilt in the draw tube (which i could not yet detect during alignment). Furthermore, there also seemed to be a tilt with the camera sensor (it is my first light with the QHY 268m). So i obtained unround stars in the corners. I tried to fix this rather aggressively. What do you think?
Actually it's very bright on my desk, i'm not sure if i got the curves properly. Will address this tonight.

Here's a raw sketch of my work flow (PI and PS)
  • Selecting and stacking the raw data
  • remove gradients with DBE
  • TGV deniose, MMT denoise
  • RGB combination, PCC, color saturation

now with the RGB and HII data:
  • HT stretch
  • Starnet++
  • extract blue channel of RGB, blend it with HII --> Luminance
  • another iteration of denoise
  • blend Luminance onto RGB

on the RGB:
  • create the Stars image from before-after Starnet++

PS actions (i'm a newbie):
  • reduce star sizes using different techniques

back in PI:
  • inverse stretching of the Stars (now it's linear again, but in 16 bit)
  • arcsinh stretch the Stars
  • try to fix unround stars using masks and MT
  • blend the resulting RGB stars into the starless image
  • some fine tuning (curves)
Helpful
Christoph Lichtblau avatar
Hallo Horst,

also zu ersteinmal ist das eine hevorragende Aufnahme. Und ja bei den Sternen gibt es ein paar Abstriche. Ein paar merkwürdige Muster um die Hellen. Ich hätte jetzt eher an einen Nachführhänger, der nicht aus dem Stack entfernt wurde gedacht. Und nicht so sehr an eine Dekollimation. Auch über eine Reflektion durch den Filter könnte man mal nachdenken. Insgesamt könnte etwas mehr Kontrast mit etwas dunklerem Hintergrund dem Bild mehr Tiefe geben. Die Grundauflösung ist schonmal sehr gut Horst.


CS, Christoph
Helpful Insightful Respectful Supportive
HR_Maurer avatar
Thank you @Christoph!
I set the curves too bright this morning, due to sunlight.
Now fixed it. This should already help a bit!
Tyler Millhouse avatar
Thank you @Christoph!
I set the curves too bright this morning, due to sunlight.
Now fixed it. This should already help a bit!

Lovely image! I am not sure if the image in the original is the one with updated curves, but I tried playing around with that one a bit... 



Here are my curves: