Nick Grundy:
What tool does everyone use to measure their polar alignment? I've been through (sharpcap, ipolar, polemaster, and now just using nina 3PPA) but they all seem somewhat fallible and what could give me ideal polar alignment in one app/process seems to contradict what another says is accurate. I feel like there should likely be some scientific measurement possible that then compare the methods?
I'd love it, but there doesn't seem to be any completely unbiased way to measure the accuracy of polar alignment that I know of. To really measure some of the tools\methods in a qualititave analysis would be awesome if anyone is up to that sort of task
Preface: there are very many issues that may affect your tracking performance that wasting time on splitting hair with PA adjustments every single night is not going to affect how things really go. My mounts are permanently mounted in my back-garden and I may check at every change of season and that's it.
However, if your mount can be exactly be positioned that the OTA is pointing to the pole (say by plate solving), take a series of shots few seconds long and covering 10 minutes of time at least. Stack them up and you'll see how good is your PA (is the Pole close to the center of the image?) if you got no cone error.
If you have a cone error then point you scope just half an hour ahead of the meridian and up to 10 degrees from the equator and keep shooting short integrations until it crosses over the meridian. The Dec drift of any chosen star will give you how accurate your PA azimuth angle is. Repeat at quadrature, either East or West (and at least 30 degrees up in altitude) and measure again the Dec drift. This will give how good your PA altitude angle is.