Doug Summers avatar
I'm new to Astrobin (1 day!).   Still learning the ropes of how to get around and how/what to add to my photos.   I have a f2.2 RASA 11 with an ASI183mcPro.   Platescale is 0.799, but I usually drizzle 2x.    PixInsight post-processing.   If you care to comment on my photos, I'm open to constructive criticism.     Cheers and thanks,   Doug S
Well Written Respectful
astropical avatar
Hello Doug,
After a quick look at your gallery I strongly believe that you did astrophotography in your previous life too,
or you are learning too quickly :-)
Cheers
Robert
Respectful Supportive
Doug Summers avatar
Hi Robert, thanks for the compliment!   Well, to be fair, I was "in the field" for 20 years before retiring.   I was an engineering professional at the Keck Observatory working LGS AO, and subsequently became the software team lead/manager at the Large Binocular Telescope.   So my learning curve for actually taking images myself has definitely been made easier than if I had zero exposure.    I was a "visual" observer before that for many years.   I started imaging in April of this year.  Still, AP has a tough learning curve for all involved details!    I  consider the fast f/2.2 RASA and low noise CMOS OSCs somewhat akin to the old starhop/goto battles of visual observing from days past.   Pretty nice results come so quickly with the newer technology.    Thanks again for commenting and looking at my images!     I'll dribble my images and populate my public page over the next month or so.    Cheers,   Doug
Well Written Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging
Elmiko avatar
Hi Doug! Nice gallery!
Mike from Phoenix area.
Doug Summers avatar
Thanks Mike!   Hopefully it will retain your high praise as I get it filled in with my other images over the next month or so….  ;-)   Cheers,  Doug
Well Written Respectful
James Newman avatar
Hello right back atcha from Colorado =)  I wish I could suggest some spots, but unfortunately most of mine are closed =(
Doug Summers avatar
Hi James, we're "lit up" with covid on the western slope….not nearly as bad as the front range though.  Good time to be imaging I guess…
Astrochromata avatar
Hi Doug,

Welcome to Astrobin! And what a great collection of pictures to start with!

The RASA is a nice telescope to fight with smile. I have just been working on the backfocus/tilt optimization and have finally found a sturdy solution that gives good flat results. Just took me 2 years to find the right hardware smile.

Looking forward to many more of your pictures!

CS,

Ray
Well Written Respectful Engaging Supportive
Doug Summers avatar
Thanks Ray!   I do really like this RASA and 183 OSC combo.   AP is a challenging hobby, but when images come out (mostly) right, it's quite a thrill.  I've not struggled with tilt (yet), but I have struggled with my CGX-L mount (it has a 0.6" magnitude 21 sec period 0.2 sec duration spike that comes from the drive belt interface to the motor…ugh nothing can be done about it but buy a better mount!).   That said, I can't complain too much…I'm still getting some good shots.   I've got a lot of images already done from earlier this year but not posted yet, and many more that are "works in progress..need more data".   I'm excited to fill in the blanks in my page and get to know folks here on Astrobin.   Cheers and thanks again,   Doug
Respectful Engaging Supportive
Astrochromata avatar
Hi Doug,

I used to have a CGX (without the -L) mount for the RASA as well (it was delivered as a set) and it was plainly too heavy with this mount to get a decent guiding. I think I tried every combination of pressure and distance on the belt drive and was always spending at least 45 minutes before I had an acceptable setting for the position of the object I was shooting.

I switched to a MESU mount a year ago and all problems were solved instantly. It is a local product here in the Netherlands so I could pick it up at the workshop. It confirmed my impression that the 11" RASA is best wielded by a non-celestron mount.

But as it is with astrophotography: if you solve one problem, you'll just run in to the next one smile
In the meantime we keep on shooting images.

CS,
Ray
Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging Supportive
Doug Summers avatar
I totally concur with the "solve one problem, on to the next one" syndrome.   I think that's what makes it so rewarding....when it all comes together.   On the CGX, it's why I got the L version (also bundled).   First surprise was the PE.  I didn't expect 17+ arcsecs.   That was easy enough to address with PECTool SW, but the very fast spike of the belt/gear interface is definitely annoying; too fast for PECTool to address.   The thing is, if they solved that, the CGX-L would be a much nicer mount.   Alas, at this price point, it's only "good enough".  When I first talked with Celestron tech support, they said the spec was "round stars".   I wish I had heard that statement before I bought  ;-)   In any case, for giggles I attach a pic of the mount PE, PE corrected, and this annoying spike.    Nice chatting with you....   Cheers,   Doug
Helpful Engaging Supportive
Astrochromata avatar
I remember that motor compartment very well smile.
Celestron tech support is virtually non-existent, especially here in Europe where "sending equipment in" is a no-no.

Looks like  the sprocket has bitten your belt, maybe you could exchange RA and DEC belt to see if that helps? On the DEC it would not bother most of the time. Plus if it turns out to be the belt, you could replace it.

Also the belt looks a bit loose to me. Celestron is doing a very bad job with the CGXes tuning the spring & belt tension on these mounts. I think I had mine running a bit tighter than that (judging from the picture).

Weight should not be so much an issue for you since you have the L version. However, the motor drive looks EXACTLY the same as on the normal CGX.

CS,
Ray
Helpful Supportive