Asiair plus guiding. How important is it to calibrate at dec between -30 and +30 ?

6 replies867 views
Eric Gagne avatar
I keep getting a warning about being far from the celestial equator when I start calibration.  The problem is I have a limited view of the sky from my shooting location this time of year and I can't point anywhere near the celestial equator. 

Guiding still seems to work so I am wondering what that warning is about.
Well written Engaging
Reg Pratt avatar
The PHD2 devs recommend calibrating no further than 20 degrees from DEC 0 and as high in altitude as possible but if you can't you can't. If your guiding has been adequate just ignore the warning. I personally have always calibrated where ever I was imaging and never had problems. I recently made a point to calibrate at dec 0 and have seen no difference in guiding performance but everyone's gear is different.
Helpful Concise
Danny Lee avatar
I receive that warning on occasion and mostly ignore it if I'm happy with how my guiding is going. Worth keeping it in mind though as if I have guiding issues I know to try recalibrating as per the ASIAir/PHD instructions as a possible fix.
Phillip Hahn avatar
My initial guiding quality is fine both ways. I do believe I get better stability over the night as the performance does not decrease that much
Greg Erianne avatar
I, too, calibrate my guiding after I slew to my target in spite of the warning.  The guiding seems absolutely fine.

Greg
Eric Gagne avatar
Thanks everyone.  You are all confirming what I thought.   It's just a warning, it's best to do it close to the celestial equator but not mandatory.
Paul Lloyd avatar
Hmm! I wonder if this is the cause of my recent guiding issue.

On consesutive nights I ran the same rig with the same guiding settings, but the guiding on the 2nd night had PHD2 changing from ~2 sec to <0.5 sec updates with a 2000ms setting. Changes to the refresh time (now set at 5000ms) made no difference. Over the 5 hours, though, there was a steady drift of the field to the point where my stacking routine just gave up, and PHD2 didn't report anything unusual!

I'm wondering whether I had got my guiding working at a point much closer to the equator on the first night, whereas I did it near my target at ~-70deg. on the 2nd night. As this was about a month ago, I can't remember that sort of detail. I'll have to try it out and let you know.

Paul.
PS Apologies in advance: this is a bit off your original topic, but might be of interest to others. Let me know if I should start up another topic.

Update: No, this isn't the same issue. This is simple user error (I say with a red face!). In the PHD2 calibration screen, I (somehow) had selected the 0.5sec exposure time. I've now put it at 3sec and all is working well. A 6-hour ap session last night couldn't have gone better! I did, however, calibrate my PHD2 while pointing at Achernar (Dec -57d), rather than the -70d of NGC2070 (Tarantula Neb.). Total RMS error for the night seems to have been mostly between 0.5" and 0.8".
Helpful Respectful
Related discussions
Struggling to guide my Star Adventurer GTi with PHD2
Hello, I first got into astrophotography two years ago and quickly began accumulating gear slowly but surely as the months went by. I recently acquired a guide scope and a guide camera to improve my exposure times, which were previously limited to ~4...
Discusses PHD2 guiding setup which may address calibration warning issues.
Apr 25, 2025