Dual band <4nm halo free OSC filters

4 replies334 views
RobertM avatar
Hi all,
 I’m looking around for a pair of ultra narrow band filters to use with my 2600mc camera.  I already have an NBZ to use with my fast scopes but need something a bit more tailored to the light polluted UK skies (Bortle 6-7).  I have had good success with the NBZ even with the Squid nebula but the contrast has been poor in my local skies.Presently I’ve been looking at the Altair Astro 4nm certified DualBand Ultra filters.  I’ve had good feedback from someone but I really need to look at  more images before deciding - they are pretty expensive and my loathing of haloes is extreme!  I’ve seen no images of known problem stars (for example Sadr, 52Cyg) so it’s a bit of a difficult investment decision.On the plus side these filters do specify out of band blocking (OD 4-5) ‘over the majority of unwanted visual wavelengths’ although cameras do have sensitivity outside the visual wavelengths.Has anyone experience if these particular filters or any others that are 4nm and have some guarantee of halo free design?  I’m not interested in wider bandwidth since I have that covered with the NBZ or those that are known to produce haloes (l-ultimate and the like).  Some images with problem stars would be great.

Any help gratefully received.
Robert
Respectful Engaging
Minh Lết avatar
Just a note, the filter is one of the major sources that causes halo but it's far from the only one. So be advised that the filter that does not cause a halo on other optics systems might cause one on yours.
RobertM avatar
Thank you and yes I am aware, however, those filters that have shown a noticable lack of halo on a number of different optical systems are likely to show the same on others also - it is this confidence that I’m after.  Some filters are now starting to quote optical density as a measure of how much out of band blocking there is as well as incorporating more effective AR coatings hence me mentioning the AA Ultra filters.

Robert
Tareq Abdulla avatar
I am planning to go with L-Ultimate as many mentioned it ha no halo or very very minimal at best, for me that is not a big deal, my main factor is contrast and narrower band for my LP sky of Bortle 8-9, i do have individual 5nm and 3nm filters which are super amazing, but i also want tor me OSC camera as i will use it mostly for RGB but sometimes for dual band if i have to, and i prefer narrower minimum halo over wider band no halo, after all the stars will be used from RGB and not NB.
RobertM avatar
I’ve ruled out the L-Ultimate as a lot of the examples I’ve seen have some sort of halo; some more severe than others.  I also have severe light pollution to deal with but I also loath halos.  I hope the L-Ultimate works out for you as it undoubtedly produces fine contrasty images.
Well Written Respectful
Related discussions
Looking for Advice on SII & OIII Filters - Halo Issues with Askar D2
Hi everyone! I need some advice on narrowband filters. I currently own the Askar D1 and D2 filters. The D1 is fantastic great colors and truly halo-free. However, while the D2 produces nice images, I’ve been struggling with halos, which is quite frus...
Discusses narrowband filters and halo issues relevant to filter selection.
Jan 29, 2025
A PSA/Rant/Warning/Opinion on CLS Filters, Light Pollution Filters, and Tri or Quad Bandpass Filters
Summary: These products are misleading in their marketing and do not return a result that is worth your money. This is intended to be a warning message that I'd copy/paste to people considering buying one of these filters, but I figured I'd p...
Critiques light pollution filters and bandpass filters for light-polluted skies.
Dec 3, 2024
Dual Band Filter Discussion
I am looking at getting into nebula imaging more and want to get a good Dual Band filter. I am using 2 different OSC cameras the asi533mc and as asi2600mc duo. I am basically in a bortle 7 I have a ZWO dual band filter but it gets halos on all my sco...
Directly addresses dual band filter selection for nebula imaging with OSC cameras.
Apr 16, 2025
Review: ToupTek 36mm LRGB and SHO Filters.
Thought I'd share my thoughts about the ToupTek Astro filters I've been using. Brilliant budget friendly filters. ToupTek Astro 36mm LRGB + SHO Filter Review. Introduction.We all know how expensive astronomy can be. Further to that, we all kn...
Reviews budget-friendly filter options that may suit author's needs.
Mar 27, 2025
Dualband Antlia ALP-T 2” 5nm vs L-Extreme 7nm
A few days ago Antlia shared pictures and info on their Facebook page about the upcoming dualband 5nm filter ALP-T. Here is comparison with the well known L-Extreme (right) (not my test, this is from their page too). So if anyone shoots from heavy li...
Seeks dual-band narrow filters for OSC camera; directly addresses ALP-T filter category.
Nov 24, 2021