Help with choosing a coma corrector

10 replies454 views
Baader MPCC or Sharpstar's 0.95x reducer?
Multiple choice poll 15 votes
20% (3 votes)
80% (12 votes)
You must be logged in to vote in this poll.
Oscar H. avatar
I'm indecisive between these two.

I use an F/5 Newtonian with 1000mm
Marc-Antonio Fischer avatar
Baader CC is not that great. Its more sensitive to tilt. 0.95 reduction is cool too smile f 4,75
Morsing avatar
Based on this: https://www.astrofotoblog.eu/?p=856 I chose the Explore Scientific CC. It has been working fine for me, though finding the correct back spacing is nor that easy, as it varies some mm with the focal length of the telescope (this may be the case for other CC's too?). It does increase focal length by x1.07, so if that is not wanted, another option may be better. The Baader one gets consistently mediocre reviews, but I have no first hand experience.

BR
Morsing
Helpful Concise
Aris Pope avatar
Starizona Nexus 0.75x hands down!! i love mine!!
Marc-Antonio Fischer avatar
Aris Pope:
Starizona Nexus 0.75x hands down!! i love mine!!

That thing is amazing! But expensive
Aris Pope avatar
Marc Fischer:
Aris Pope:
Starizona Nexus 0.75x hands down!! i love mine!!

That thing is amazing! But expensive

 Yes but worth every penny.  https://starizona.com/products/starizona-nexus-0-75x-newtonian-focal-reducer-coma-corrector
Marc-Antonio Fischer avatar
Aris Pope:
Marc Fischer:
Aris Pope:
Starizona Nexus 0.75x hands down!! i love mine!!

That thing is amazing! But expensive

 Yes but worth every penny.  https://starizona.com/products/starizona-nexus-0-75x-newtonian-focal-reducer-coma-corrector

Yes. Here in germany 300€ more expensive
Marc-Antonio Fischer avatar
deleted avatar
Aris Pope:
Starizona Nexus 0.75x hands down!! i love mine!!

Is the Starnoza Nexus 0,75x a good coma corrector for an F5 telescope? (150/750 here)
jmdl101 avatar
I love my Nexus, and I also have no issues with my HRCC02. Starizona makes the nexus without the stop collar also, to give more inward travel for people that need it, like dslr users normally.
Oscar H. avatar
I think the Nexus is the best, maybe I should save money for it because it's about $190 over my budget. It would give me 750mm and F/3.75 which is really nice.

According to this FOV calculator website, this is how the Pleiades and Orion Nebula will be framed with my camera.
The purple is uncropped full-frame.
The the light blue is with a 1.6x crop (which I will use).


Below is the same framing size, but with the Orion nebula.

Overall, I really like the Nexus.
Related discussions
Problem with M54 extender and coma corrector.
I have a TSFMA360 focuser that I want to use with a TS 1.0x coma corrector for Newtonian telescopes, so that the corrector can be screwed into the focuser. I have an adapter to be able to screw it in.The problem is that, because the drawtube of the f...
Relevant - discusses coma corrector usage with Newtonian telescopes and focuser compatibility issues.
Sep 16, 2024