Help! WO GT81 Field Curvature Issues

5 replies236 views
Kyle Desrosier avatar
Hi all. I'm having some serious field curvature issues with my William Optics Gran Turismo 81. I have the WO Flat 6AII adjustable field flattener/reducer and have set it to roughly 7.9mm like the sales page suggests (https://agenaastro.com/william-optics-0-8x-reducer-adjustable-field-flattener-6aii-p-flat6aii.html), but the stars are still very oblong in the corners. I experimented last night for about 3 hours, moving the field flattener about a full rotation in each direction from my starting point but didn't see much difference in the curvature at all.

This is causing a lot of problems when trying to stack subs that are on different sides of the meridian flip. The curvature is different in each corner so the stars don't line up well when the camera is rotated 180°. It gets even worse when I try to align my narrowband frames in Photoshop. For example, I took Ha and OIII before a flip, and SII afterwards. After aligning them, stars in the corners are biased towards red (SII) or green/blue (Ha/OIII) depending on how misaligned they are from each other.

I can see the benefit to a camera rotator here, but I feel like that's a band-aid.

Can anyone lend some advice? Am I maybe just expecting a perfectly flat field that I will just never get?

Thanks!
Well written Engaging
Robert Huerbsch avatar
I have not gotten a perfectly flat field but have come close on full frame. I’m using a GT71 tho @ 9mm
Kyle Desrosier avatar
I'm using a 4/3 sensor ( ZWO ASI1600MM). I wonder if that has something to do with it.
keithlt avatar
i use this its oem for the gt81 https://agenaastro.com/william-optics-2-0-8x-reducer-field-flattener-gt81.html
maybe the new adjustable type has to many variables .
Robert Huerbsch avatar
It should be much easier with the smaller 4/3 sensor, you should be able to get pin point stars across the entire frame. If the adjustable part is not tight you will get some tilt and one corner will be bad
Kyle Desrosier avatar
I did find that some of my extender tubes were loose last night. I think in adjusting the FF, I possible loosened things and caused more tilt. I also discovered that I have ~56.7mm of backfocus between the rear flange of the FF and the camera sensor, when William Optics specifies that there should be 54.8mm. I'm going to adjust the FF to account and try again the next chance I get.
Related discussions
Article: Sensor Tilt Adjustment
Hi everyone, I would like to share here a methodology that I developed to check tilt in our optical systems. With the arrival of the new CMOS cameras, with those really small pixels, tilt and other issues have become more noticeable. I suffered tilt ...
Sensor tilt can cause corner star distortion similar to field curvature issues.
Dec 28, 2020
need a little help with William Optics Flat73R
I am having a devil of a time trying to get my field totally flat. now i am using a zwo asi183mm pro with the william optics z73 with flat 73r and a filter wheel. it said to adjust the ring back 1.8mm for a camera with 17.5mm backfocus.. i did and no...
Direct experience with William Optics field flattener adjustment and troubleshooting.
Oct 17, 2020