Askar 151PHQ or Sky-Watcher Esprit 150EDX?

1 reply71 views
Photon_Collector avatar

Which would you go for for remote imaging?

I’m not sure how the new Esprits will be but I assume top notch. Build quality on the Askars can be variable but I’ve seen some phenomenal results with the 151PHQ.

Engaging
SonnyE avatar

I would get the PHQ. I’ve had great results with my Triplets over the years, but the quads are here and proven now.

Besides, there is nothing to add. I needed to add an FR/FF to my 130mm Triplet to get the picture the ads promised. It also dropped the telescope from the 910mm F7, down to 728mm F5.8. So what I thought I was buying wasn’t quite what I had hoped. I’m happy with my present results, but feel the ad writers lied about it.

From my understanding a quad doesn’t need anything added or subtracted. I’d get the quad, hands down. You get what you’re paying for.

Well written Helpful Concise Engaging Supportive
Related discussions
How to Make an good astronomical mount with the EQ8-R (or ORION HD110) using Shibumi Astro Kits (long post with photos)
Hi all, This is my first post here. I'm not an English speaker, so I apologize in advance if there are any language errors in the post. There's little practical information online about improving the quality of the Chinese-made EQ8-R. Or Orion HD110 ...
Discusses mounts for remote imaging setups; relevant to equipment selection discussion.
Mar 10, 2026
My littte bad weather project: Sharpstar 13028HNT modification
Due to bad weather in Germany, I wanted to do some modifications to my Sharpstar 13028HNT. I’d like to share my first experiences with these modifications, though there is still more to do. A few things I wanted to try:Create a new mirror mask (notch...
Covers telescope modifications and experiences; potentially relevant to equipment quality/performance topic.
Dec 12, 2025