Mysterious U-shaped structure near NGC 2477 and NGC 2546?

4 replies270 views
Vin avatar

What is this structure near NGC 2477 and NGC 2451 in Puppis? If you flip between the star and starless versions you can see it looks like an inverted U or upside down horseshoe. Its almost like a smoke ring or pressure tube - does anyone know what it is pls?

https://cdn.astrobin.com/thumbs/zBVdJeuW76Xy_1824x0__sPnTECk.png?v=1773073285

https://app.astrobin.com/i/a6ygfl if easier to see it by doing a mouseover

(Sorry its NGC 2451 not NGC 2546 but I don’t know how to change the title)

SonnyE avatar

I’ve looked at this for two days and I think you need to be more specific Vin.

Can you highlight or circle what has your curiosity peaked?

Vin avatar

SonnyE · Mar 10, 2026 at 03:53 PM

I’ve looked at this for two days and I think you need to be more specific Vin.

Can you highlight or circle what has your curiosity peaked?

Apologies Sonny. I’ll try and upload two starless versions where I’ve marked (in GIMP) pencil lines along side the contours. If you go to revision I in my image and do a mouseover you’ll see that the tubes seem quite distinct (once you see them, you can’t unsee them).

HOSwRGBstars_24h24_starless._annotated.jpg

HSH_11h00_starless_annotated.jpg

Helpful Respectful
Vin avatar

@SonnyE you can also see it near NGC2451 in this one: https://app.astrobin.com/i/dneo0m - it’s like a hollow tube. Would love to know how these are formed!

SonnyE avatar

Yeah, I see what you are wondering about, now.

But no, no explanation.

Thank You for clarifying what you were asking about.

Related discussions
Is there a name for Sh2-204?
Does anybody know the official Name for this target? I have caputed this version of this rarely captured beauty: https://app.astrobin.com/u/pmneo?i=96df48#gallery It reminds me to the Shrimp Nebula: https://app.astrobin.com/u/pmneo?i=zg6bfu#gallery C...
Author captured rare nebula; identifying unknown astronomical objects is relevant.
Sep 30, 2025
Request for help checking Astrobin first discoveries
Please could I request your help and advice? There are 3 images and I would like to know if they were Astrobin firsts when they were posted. O III arc 7° long in HOO near SNR G206.9 + 2.3 https://app.astrobin.com/u/huntinghorn?collection=45383&i=...
Author questions potential astronomical discovery; similar to seeking Astrobin first verification.
Feb 28, 2026