Photographing comet 3I/ATLAS: guiding issues with RC10 telescope setup

2 replies104 views
marcomas avatar

Hi everyone, I’m looking for some info… I’d like to try photographing a comet, specifically 3I/ATLAS, weather permitting. I don’t have any experience with this kind of imaging.
My setup is an RC10 f/8 with an ASI 294MM, an ASI 174MM OAG on a GM2000 QCI. I’m using 60-second exposures.
I tried last week using NINA and its Orbitals plugin, but something went wrong: I pointed the telescope at the comet and it was centered in the frame, but when I started guiding, the graph was completely messed up.
What am I doing wrong? Why isn’t the guiding working? Are the exposures too long? Should I set things up differently compared to classic deep-sky guiding? PHD2? Or should I just give up because of the long focal length?
Thanks.

Guido Haak avatar
Stu Todd avatar

If you are using an OAG and have changed your fl, you need to tell PhD and run a guiding recalibration in the PhD tools.

Let us know how you get on.

Related discussions
Eclipse… and a comet?
So it looks like it may be possible to image the total eclipse AND comet 12P… In the same frame! (During totality) Now, since I’ve never taken a pic of either one, and there is no time for me to mess around to figure out exposures, I’d like to hear s...
Relevant experience with comet photography exposure and technique planning.
Mar 14, 2024
Using a ZWO 2600MC Duo with a long focal length scope
I am considering buying a ZWO 2600MC Duo to use on our astronomy club Celestron edge C14 with the 0.7 reducer. This will mean I won't need a guide scope or off axis guider. Has anyone had experience using the Duo on a long focal length scope (C14...
Directly addresses guiding issues with RC telescope; relevant to guiding performance questions.
Jan 23, 2024
Comet Lemmon Data Up for Review – Banding / Pixelation Issue
I’m returning to DSO astrophotography after nearly eight years away, and needless to say, my PixInsight skills needed quite a bit of refreshing. I’m using the same setup as before, but I’ve switched to a Sony A7 IV DSLR for imaging because of its ver...
Author photographing comet; candidate discusses comet photography techniques and troubleshooting.
Oct 14, 2025
Blasted through the high clouds last night, interesting experiment... NGC 2064.
Last night I just went for it despite the unfavorable skies. I had cloud patterns that were semitransparent, so for one thing ASTAP was finicky to solve. Until I went back into my options in NINA and increased my exposure time for plate solving. The ...
Addresses guiding issues similar to author's PHD2 troubleshooting experience.
Mar 2, 2026
Struggling to improve my telescope guiding performance
I’ve been struggling to improve my guiding for a couple of months now, despite any changes I make it doesn’t seem to have a major effect for improving my total rms. Gear Used:Sky Watcher 150iExplore Scientific ED102ZWO OAGZWO ASI 120MM Relevant Setti...
Author experiencing guiding issues with comet imaging setup and software.
Feb 20, 2026