M31 Andromeda Galaxy looking for critiques

3 replies205 views
Dave Stearn avatar

I finally settled on this version of M31 reprocessing M31 a few times.

I have seen different version of M31. I add the Ha using Continuum Subtraction and adding Ha to RGB scripts in Pixisinsight.

I finally fixed my star issue by not using a CC template with auto detect on. I just set WBPP Color Calibration on Auto.

Drizzle 2X and then Integer Resample down 2 median after running BlurXT.

Let me know what you think.

https://app.astrobin.com/i/eykt0u

Tony Gondola avatar

I think this is a fine M31. Colors are not over baked and the core isn’t blown out. Star colors look good. It’s a good middle of the road, wide field M31.

Well Written Concise
Marco Montella avatar

I like it! Colors pop naturally in both the galaxy and the stars, which were not reduced excessively in prominence. The dynamic range is good and there’s no trace of residuals of artificial gradients hiding in M31’s extended halo.

A question from a perspective of relative inexperience: what is the purpose of the “Drizzle > BXT > Resample” pipeline? Is it to nullify stacking artefacts?

Dave Stearn avatar

Thanks Marco,

It’s to resample the image back down to the native resolution. I use Drizzle 2X since the image is undersampled but the file size is large and processing intensive. There are several tutorials on YT that demonstrate using Blur XT and then using Integer Resample. I use 2X down median.

After that I run my workflow.

Helpful
Related discussions
Request for constructive criticism
RCC: https://app.astrobin.com/i/dj9ou5 Happy Halloween!
M31 Andromeda critique — seeking critiques on reprocessed galaxy image.
Oct 31, 2025
How do my stars look?
I have been working on my workflow for OSC Narrowband using the Askar SQA 55 and the 2600MC Pro. I drizzle 2X and then Resample down 2X to the native resolution after DBE and BlurXT. I use Bill Blanshan’s SHO Colorization script. In this case I used ...
Similar narrowband galaxy processing workflow with drizzle and resample techniques.
Dec 6, 2025
Feedback Request: 2 different versions of my Rho-Region Mosaic
Hi there, bin.com/u/MichaelCR97?i=ls835a#gallery / https://app.astrobin.com/u/MichaelCR97?i=kprzie#gallery What things do you see here that could be improved? And what version do you like more? Best regards, Michael
Author reprocessed image multiple times seeking critique and feedback.
Dec 6, 2025
Critique my image!
Hello everybody, ive recently finished one of my largest projects yet, a 115h integration of Bodes Galaxy in HaLRGB, and I was looking for some criticism, because sometimes im blind to some problems Ive done in my editing, was looking to get some fre...
Author seeks critiques on galaxy image; similar RCC request and HaLRGB processing.
Apr 12, 2025
PixInsight Processing Question – Adding Ha to a RGB Image
I have been looking through YT off and on for 2 days and haven’t come across a good video on how to add Ha to a RGB image. Many of the processes available within PixInsight use a Blend or Add function. IMO this has a tendency to destroy fine details ...
Demonstrates Ha addition via continuum subtraction method author referenced.
Feb 12, 2026