A question for RASA owners

6 replies152 views
For you RASA, are you using a OSC or mono and filter sliders?
Multiple choice poll 20 votes
0% (0 votes)
25% (5 votes)
0% (0 votes)
35% (7 votes)
0% (0 votes)
25% (5 votes)
15% (3 votes)
You must be logged in to vote in this poll.
ScottF avatar

Hi,

I recently purchased an 11” RASA and I’m using a 2600mm with filter sliders. I typically use one NB filter per night, take flats in the morning, then swap the filter for the next NB filter. For strictly NB imaging it seems ok, but I find it a lot of trouble to do RGB stars. I’m curious about swapping the camera for a OSC camera and using dual narrowband filters for NB and a LP filter so I can capture RGB stars in one go. What is everyone using, and reasoning?

thank you

Scott

Engaging
Nicolas Molina avatar

Hi Scott.

I have a RASA 8, but it’s basically the same problem. I started with the 2600 mm, but I changed it to the 2600 mc pro because of what you mentioned. My choice was the IDAS NBZ. I would not recommend typical 3nm dual-band filters; they are not preshifted to use on fast telescopes.

CS

Nicolás

churmey avatar

If the RASA is your dedicated instrument, my advice is to keep things simple, and get the same camera in both mono and OSC. In my case, I will image with the mono for Lum or Narrowband, then simply switch cameras when doing color. I never switch during a session….In other words, I’ll image 1 full night in Lum, or several nights, until I complete Lum. Then I’ll switch and image OSC a full night or until I complete RGB and so on…. I have used this system with both the 183m/mc and now use the 2600m/mc.

Helpful
ScottF avatar

churmey · Oct 27, 2025 at 03:21 PM

If the RASA is your dedicated instrument, my advice is to keep things simple, and get the same camera in both mono and OSC. In my case, I will image with the mono for Lum or Narrowband, then simply switch cameras when doing color. I never switch during a session….In other words, I’ll image 1 full night in Lum, or several nights, until I complete Lum. Then I’ll switch and image OSC a full night or until I complete RGB and so on…. I have used this system with both the 183m/mc and now use the 2600m/mc.

So you are fixing tilt after each switch? I’ve only done it once so far, but it was a fairly time consuming, onerous experience. lol

ScottF avatar

churmey · Oct 27, 2025 at 03:21 PM

If the RASA is your dedicated instrument, my advice is to keep things simple, and get the same camera in both mono and OSC. In my case, I will image with the mono for Lum or Narrowband, then simply switch cameras when doing color. I never switch during a session….In other words, I’ll image 1 full night in Lum, or several nights, until I complete Lum. Then I’ll switch and image OSC a full night or until I complete RGB and so on…. I have used this system with both the 183m/mc and now use the 2600m/mc.

So you are fixing tilt after each switch? I’ve only done it once so far, but it was a fairly time consuming, onerous experience. lol

Nicolas Molina avatar

I agree. Tilt adjustment is something I don’t want to do very often.

Well Written
churmey avatar

ScottF · Oct 27, 2025 at 03:31 PM

churmey · Oct 27, 2025 at 03:21 PM

If the RASA is your dedicated instrument, my advice is to keep things simple, and get the same camera in both mono and OSC. In my case, I will image with the mono for Lum or Narrowband, then simply switch cameras when doing color. I never switch during a session….In other words, I’ll image 1 full night in Lum, or several nights, until I complete Lum. Then I’ll switch and image OSC a full night or until I complete RGB and so on…. I have used this system with both the 183m/mc and now use the 2600m/mc.

So you are fixing tilt after each switch? I’ve only done it once so far, but it was a fairly time consuming, onerous experience. lol

I suppose I’m just lucky, but my flat field falls within my personal tolerance. There is some, it’s minimal but it’s not to the degree that I have to spend time on it especially after final edit. If it was outside of my tolerance, I certainly would move to a different method.

Related discussions
Over correcting flats with fix
Howdy all. I've been rather bummed with the quality of my images for the last 9 months. I have data collected for two projects that I never finished due to the poor quality. Recently I discovered that my flats were over correcting my LRGB images ...
Not relevant - focuses on flat correction issues, not filter/camera strategy.
Aug 17, 2025
Adding Dual-Narrowband data to an OSC image
Hello everyone. After 2 months of cloudy nights I finally caught a night when I can take my telescope outside. For my next target I decided to image M 33. I bought a UV/IR cut filter and have been using that for the first night of collecting data. I ...
Relevant - directly addresses combining dual-narrowband with OSC for RGB stars.
Sep 19, 2025
36mm filters in 2" filter wheel?
Hi all, I was set on moving from DSLR to mono this year but I think I will go with and ASP-C OSC(2600MC pro) in the end. There hasn’t been a fully clear night since the end of September and I’m not sure if I would be able to make the best use of Mono...
Relevant - discusses OSC camera consideration and filter wheel compatibility.
Nov 9, 2025
QHYCCD Minicam8 Mono SPCC Filter Setup
Hi Everyone, I know that Minicam8 mono users here are using some sort of color calibration in PI. I have been comfortably shooting OSC for years. I am new to mono and was hoping that I might get some help from some folks using this camera with settin...
Relevant - addresses transitioning from OSC to mono with color filter setup.
Sep 8, 2025