How to identify bad darks?

2 replies80 views
Arny avatar

I just took the annual update of my set of darks for my 2 cooled astro cameras - and everything ran fine during the day under a dark hood all caps closed.

Stacking them to masterDarks with WBPP worked fine and the resulting masterDarks as well as the single frames looked fine without gradients when looked at in STF.

BUT when I did a testrun calibrating good imaging data where the old darks had worked perfectly well, all images came out of WBPP with massive gradients.

So I assume I must have picke up some stray light when taking the darks, as it was during the day.

=> Has anyone got an idea or best practice to identify poor darks earlier in the process?

I tried 2dplot script and found a tiny gradient across some of the darks - but nothing that would add up to th eeffect I noticed in the wbpp processed images.

Arny

Mikołaj Wadowski avatar

If your darks are too bright, your flats will not correct properly, which is probably why you’re seeing gradients.

If you have a dark frame you’re sure had no light leaks, compare it with other dark frames. The median value of a dark frame should always stay the same for a given temperature and exposure length, so any significant deviation would indicate stray light is hitting the sensor.

Well Written Helpful Insightful Concise
Craig Towell avatar

Yeah look at the average pixel value of the darks, they shouldn’t vary more than a coupe of ADU compared to a good dark frame.

E.g. with my 533mm the good darks are ave 2875 so when I’m taking new darks I know any more than that and light is getting in somewhere.

Related discussions
Gradient in dark frames
Hi everyone! I recently bought the Player One Poseidon C Pro camera and after a very long period of cloudy nights it finally cleared and I got to try it. When taking the lights everything was normal. When the sun rose again the pictures got very satu...
Guidance on identifying problematic dark frames relevant to flat dark issues.
Mar 5, 2026
Checkerboard pattern after stacking and star removal?
Hi all, This morning I stacked together some WIP data collected so far just to see how it's looking. No processing other than: - 45x300sec stacked with darks only (no flats, dark flats) Stacking with WBPP and in DSS produces the same result - Dyn...
Author used darks only; understanding dark frame quality is relevant.
Oct 24, 2023
My flats and darks are brighter than my lights
I was using Siril for preprocessing and when calibrating my lights I was getting an error message that 99% of my pixels have negative values after subtracting darks. After some troubleshooting I found that the average pixel values of my darks and bia...
Directly addresses identifying and troubleshooting problematic dark calibration frames.
May 17, 2024
WBPP Stacking generates Black and White result from OSC Light frames
Have faced a peculiar issue during WBPP Stacking in Pixinsight for two sets of of light frames . Others seem to work fine I have a OSC ASI 533 MC Pro along with Askar SQA 55 and my recent exposures of M42 and NGC 1499 have generated a black and white...
WBPP stacking issues with light frames; gradients problem similar to yours.
14 days ago
Player One Poseidon M camera showing clustered hot pixels in dark frames
Hello everybody, I recently bought a Player One Poseidon M camera (analogous to ZWO’s ASI2600-M Pro). The camera hasn't had its first light yet, because the weather has been bad and the filters haven’t arrived yet. However, I took bias and dark frame...
Dark frame quality issues with cooled cameras; hot pixels affect calibration.
Dec 14, 2025