Autofocus questions

5 replies263 views
Dave Wilton avatar
In the past, I've generally run an autofocus every 30 minutes (I don't have a temperature gauge on my rig). But I've recently switched to NINA and have used the autofocus on HFR change (default of 5% over 10 images). But no autofocus run was triggered during the entire night. The temperature change during the night was only 5.5 C (10 F), and I was using a Redcat 51 with an image scale of 3.1 arcsec/pixel. The images have come out fine, and I'm assuming there just wasn't a need for any autofocus runs.

Am I correct in assuming that given a more severe change in temperature or a different scope/resolution, an autofocus run might have been triggered?

Also, am I correct in believing that HFR variance is a better metric for triggering an autofocus run that temperature change alone, since HFR change is a direct measure of the need for refocusing?
Well Written Engaging
Tony Gondola avatar

I don’t think HFR is a good guide for when to adjust focus because it can vary a lot as the seeing changes through the night. Temp at the Objective would be a better guide. I think that once you know your rig really well, you’ll know how big a temp shift needs to be to push you out of the CFZ. If you study your HFR log you’ll see the trends. Seeing usually but not always will be up and down. Focus shift do to temp will be a constant trend in the data. It’s pretty unmistakable when you see it.

Helpful Insightful Concise
Tom Marsala avatar
I agree with Tony here. Especially in my large newt where seeing changes and wind conditions are less than optional, my rig would focus almost every five minutes  when I was working with just HFR.  I finally settled on just temperature as the main variable when using NINA.
Tom
andrea tasselli avatar
Dave Wilton:
Also, am I correct in believing that HFR variance is a better metric for triggering an autofocus run that temperature change alone, since HFR change is a direct measure of the need for refocusing?


*For small apertures, short focal length HFR is a good metric to trigger autofocus, and the core of the temperature sensitivity might be more on lens' temperature than air temperature.
Tobiasz avatar

Refocus on % HFR change does an autofocus when your images are already blurry while a refocus on temperature change tries to prevent your images getting blurry.

Even my steel RC with f/8 lost its best focus when the temperature moved around 1°C to 1.2°C.

I would recommend setting two triggers:

Autofocus every x min

Autofocus on x°C temperature change

Nina will reset the “autofocus every x min” timer if an autofocus already happened because of the temperature. This way you can make sure to have the best focus all the time.

But the temperature probe needs to be accurate, if its temperature jumps around to quickly you will never stop auto-focusing.

Helpful
Nedim Bevrnja avatar

Hi Dave!

With my 150P Quattro at f/3.45 I’ve never had any focus drift during a session that was caused purely by temperature changes. I run this setup entirely with HocusFocus (the NINA plugin), and so far it has given me the best and most consistent results.

With my RC16 it’s a different story, since temperature will definitely play a role there due to the long focal length and the mechanical design.

My takeaway: start with HFR using HocusFocus and observe how your telescope behaves. If the results aren’t satisfying, you can always switch over to temperature-based focusing later.


CS
Nedim

Well Written Helpful Insightful Respectful Engaging Supportive
Related discussions
How long does it take to auto-focus?
Never did this and I wouldn't but I may have to. So this is the question: Suppose to have to refocus during an acquisition run using NINA, how long would it take with an autofocuser (any EAF really) to achieve focus starting close to focus. For e...
Relevant - author uses NINA autofocus and may need duration information.
21 days ago
NINA failing to run triggers, etc.
NINA is not recording exposure info, not adding target name to file, not running any triggers such as AF after HFR increase, not running AF after filter change, not setting last filter on autofocus, not flipping at meridian. 1st time I’ve encountered...
Autofocus questions; directly addresses AF trigger issues mentioned.
Dec 12, 2025
External focuser on an SCT; What about temperature change induced focal shift and back-focus?
It seems like every serious astro-photographer is putting external focusers on the back of the EdgeHD telescopes and locking the mirrors. I picked up a nice little EdgeHD 8" and a Primaluce Lab Esatto 2" LP focuser and gave it a try myself....
Relevant - author discusses temperature-induced focus shift and autofocus strategy.
12 days ago
Focuser trouble when NINA starts
Hello, I’m new to NINA (was using ASIAIR before), I was able to connect and set everything and to perform two nights of imaging. Here is my issue, the last two times I turned all my equipment on, my focus was lost (I mean stars wereway out of focus, ...
Autofocus questions — addresses focus loss issues between imaging sessions.
Sep 3, 2025
TOA-130 temperature / focus management strategies?
Finally have my TOA-130 up and running at DSP remote in New Mexico. TOA-130 is definitely very sensitive to changes in temperature. I have a moonlight nightcrawler 3.5" installed on it. I was looking at my imaging history last night in NINA, and...
Autofocus frequency strategies relevant to temperature-induced focus drift issues.
Dec 29, 2024