Generic Upgrade path.

Sky-Watcher Star Adventurer GTi William Optics Redcat 51 Equipment Beginner Buying Advice
6 replies•266 views
Johnathan Allison avatar
Johnathan Allison avatar
Hello all. I am working with a $1500 budget and I am trying to not just click buy now on gear I ay not need I am uneducated in appropriate upgrade paths.. 

Current Gear list:
  1. Full spectrum modified Canon T3. I also have an Unmodified Canon SL2.
  2. Other than the two kits lenses, I have a Rokinon 135MM F2
  3. Mount is a Skywatcher Star Adventurer GTI

I was thinking about just getting a redcat 51 Gen3 can keeping the cameras. I like the 250MM Focal Length and I am comfortable working the DSLR's. I am just unsure what the correct decision is here. I feel overwhelmed by the options in scopes and astro cameras. I don't have a lot of experience is Astrophotography other than using the Seestar which is why I thought to just upgrade the optics. Please educate me.

Thank you.
andrea tasselli avatar
andrea tasselli avatar
Stick to the GTi and the Rokinon (which is better than the Redcat) and get a better camera 'cause a T3 is really very old tech. Get an IMX533 based cooled camera and that is another world. If you can afford it, an IMX571 based camera is even a better choice but the IMX533 will still give you reasonably large vistas and a good sampling given the focal length of the lens.
Johnathan Allison avatar
Johnathan Allison avatar
andrea tasselli:
Stick to the GTi and the Rokinon (which is better than the Redcat) and get a better camera 'cause a T3 is really very old tech. Get an IMX533 based cooled camera and that is another world. If you can afford it, an IMX571 based camera is even a better choice but the IMX533 will still give you reasonably large vistas and a good sampling given the focal length of the lens.

I am taking a liking to wide field vistas. I have a seestar that I use for "Portrait" shoots of DSO's lol. I like the large field images of gas and dust.
TiffsAndAstro avatar
TiffsAndAstro avatar
andrea tasselli:
Stick to the GTi and the Rokinon (which is better than the Redcat) and get a better camera 'cause a T3 is really very old tech. Get an IMX533 based cooled camera and that is another world. If you can afford it, an IMX571 based camera is even a better choice but the IMX533 will still give you reasonably large vistas and a good sampling given the focal length of the lens.

I am taking a liking to wide field vistas. I have a seestar that I use for "Portrait" shoots of DSO's lol. I like the large field images of gas and dust.


I have a 533 colour and it's very nice to use with seemingly good results.
It will have a much smaller field of view than your dslr.
Maybe have a look on telescopius, put in your gear and compare?
I use mine on a 420mm scope, but need mosaics for anything rose nebula (doesn't quite fit)
This is the only downside I can see however. Everything with a cooled osc is so much smoother than with my old dslr
Supportive
dkamen avatar
dkamen avatar
Hello all. I am working with a $1500 budget and I am trying to not just click buy now on gear I ay not need I am uneducated in appropriate upgrade paths.. 

Current Gear list:
  1. Full spectrum modified Canon T3. I also have an Unmodified Canon SL2.
  2. Other than the two kits lenses, I have a Rokinon 135MM F2
  3. Mount is a Skywatcher Star Adventurer GTI

I was thinking about just getting a redcat 51 Gen3 can keeping the cameras. I like the 250MM Focal Length and I am comfortable working the DSLR's. I am just unsure what the correct decision is here. I feel overwhelmed by the options in scopes and astro cameras. I don't have a lot of experience is Astrophotography other than using the Seestar which is why I thought to just upgrade the optics. Please educate me.

Thank you.

It is not focal length that matters (unless you are doing planetary). It is aperture and f/number. The Rokinon outperforms the Redcat in both dimensions, even when stopped down to f/2.5 which makes it super sharp. It is also significantly lighter. It truly is an amazing instrument for wide field and going to the RC51 would be a downgrade. I agree with Andrea. The upgrade that makes more sense for you is to a cooled camera plus of course the necessary adaptors for achieving 55mm flange distance. In addition to much lower noise and higher sensitivity, a cooled 533 sensor (or its bigger brother) have 25% smaller pixels which means you will be able to achieve 33% higher detail. Is this worth $1000-$1500? Your call. But it is the only upgrade path that makes sense given what you have.  You already are very close to optimal as it happens, so putting in X money+effort gives you much less than X improvement.  

Cheers,
Dimitris
Well Written Helpful Insightful Engaging Supportive
andrea tasselli avatar
andrea tasselli avatar
The upgrade that makes more sense for you is to a cooled camera plus of course the necessary adaptors for achieving 55mm flange distance.


Ahem, you obviously meant 44mm flange distance since the lens is for a Canon DSLR.
dkamen avatar
dkamen avatar
andrea tasselli:
The upgrade that makes more sense for you is to a cooled camera plus of course the necessary adaptors for achieving 55mm flange distance.


Ahem, you obviously meant 44mm flange distance since the lens is for a Canon DSLR.

Yes
Related discussions
Review of my past work and the future upgrade path
Hello AB friends/ colleagues here, Let me start with a disclaimer: This is my first post in a forum. I have been little too hesitant to post this here because already too many questions on the same topic have been asked and answered. I have gone thro...
Budget-conscious upgrade planning with gear selection guidance relevant to poster's concerns.
Mar 5, 2023
New Refractor
Hello, I am seeking your advice about purchasing a new scope. I have ZWO 294 mm pro and Sony A7III Astromodified , Mount is Skywatcher HEQ5 . I want to upgrade from the Redcat 51 to longer focal length , 600 mm or a few more , I am thinking in ASKAR ...
Similar budget and upgrade path decision-making for astrophotography equipment.
Jun 2, 2023
Upgrade priorities (new scope or new camera)
With a somewhat limited budget, I am trying to decide what my upgrade priorities should be in the coming year.I am currently using a William Optics Zenithstar 61 refractor (with flattener) and an unmodified full frame Nikon D750 DSLR on a Skywatcher ...
Directly relevant—addresses upgrade path planning with budget constraints.
Mar 8, 2023
BEGINNER: Best Scope for Deepsky and Planetary imaging
Hey guys, I'm a literally bloody beginner and so far have only used my canon 600d untracked on a tripod. But I was limited very fast so now I want to upgrade my setup. I'm looking for a beginner friendly scope which I can shoot the most commo...
Generic Upgrade path. — budget-conscious equipment upgrade guidance for astrophotography beginners
Jan 20, 2023
I don't know what to do. Buy a dedicated camera or telescope to improve my actual equipment?
Hello all! Hi, after a long time saving, I put together a good amount and I am looking and investigating to see what I can buy. There are thousands of options out there and I'm not very informed on the subject of dedicated cameras, that's why...
Directly addresses upgrade path planning with budget constraints.
Dec 31, 2022